Edward Mead Earle and “Makers of Modern Strategy” with Michael Finch
Nov 24, 2024
auto_awesome
Michael Finch, author of "Making Makers: The Past, The Present, and the Study of War," dives into the significant historical impact of "Makers of Modern Strategy" edited by Edward Mead Earle. He discusses Earle's insights on totalitarianism and his role in shaping military history as a discipline. The conversation highlights the evolution of American security seminars and the intricate relationship between academic and military strategy. Finch also touches on Earle's blend of military, political, and societal elements in grand strategy, revealing its relevance across various historical contexts.
Edward Mead Earle significantly influenced American military strategy discussions during and after WWII, emphasizing public understanding of complex global issues.
The evolution of military history studies shifted from a narrow focus on battles to a broader examination of political, economic, and societal contexts surrounding warfare.
Deep dives
Edward Meade Earle's Influence
Edward Meade Earle emerged as a key figure in military history, significantly shaping discussions around American strategy during and after World War II. Initially a history professor, he became a central figure at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, where he gathered scholars to address pressing wartime issues. Earle aimed to involve the American public in strategic discussions, believing that understanding military affairs was crucial beyond just times of conflict. His concerns were fueled by the rise of totalitarianism before the war and the need for a populace informed about the complexities of international relations.
The Evolution of Military History
Military history underwent a transformation in the early 20th century, evolving from a central domain of study to a more marginalized position within academia. Initially viewed as a critical field, military history started to face criticisms for its narrow focus on battle narratives, neglecting broader social contexts that explain warfare's significance. This decline came alongside emerging challenges, as scholars sought to redefine military history's scope to include economic, political, and societal influences. Notably, Hans Delbruck's approach advocated for an integrated view of military history that encompassed these wider aspects, emphasizing the need for coherence between military actions and broader historical phenomena.
The Role of the Institute for Advanced Study
Founded by Abraham Flexner, the Institute for Advanced Study aimed to prioritize research without the constraints of teaching, fostering an environment for scholars to explore complex ideas. Earle's tenure at the institute coincided with its formative years, characterized by a dynamic atmosphere where various academic disciplines interacted, albeit with tension. Flexner envisioned it as a space for unbiased pursuit of knowledge, but tensions arose as scholars focused on contemporary issues rather than detached research. Earle capitalized on this environment to direct discussions towards American security and grand strategy, integrating current events with academic inquiry.
The Legacy of 'Makers of Modern Strategy'
The book 'Makers of Modern Strategy' serves as an essential cornerstone in the study of military thought and strategic studies, articulating a broader conception of strategy beyond military tactics. Earle viewed strategy as an evolving concept encompassing political, economic, and social dimensions, calling for a continuous understanding that extends into peacetime. The publication, while rooted in discussions from Earle’s seminar, reflects a collaborative effort involving various émigré scholars who contributed their insights. Its dual-layered approach, addressing historical military thought while responding to the ongoing global conflict, exemplifies the interplay between historical scholarship and contemporary geopolitical challenges.
In 1943, the book “Makers of Modern Strategy” was released and was an immediate success. The editor, Edward Mead Earle, had hoped to offer the public a historical lens through which to understand a world in the midst of a global war. Joining us to talk about the book, its intellectual history, and legacy is Michael Finch. Finch is the author of “Making Makers: The Past, The Present, and the Study of War.”
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode