Aymann Ismail, a Muslim journalist, and Emily Tamkin, a writer and author, discuss power dynamics, tribalism, and the role of empathy in the Israel-Gaza conflict's impact on the United States. They share personal experiences, address online dialogue challenges, explore historical support for Israel among American Jews, delve into frustration and pain, discuss power imbalances and silenced voices, and debunk misnomers about the conflict.
The podcast emphasizes the need for open dialogue and understanding amidst the ripple effects of the Gaza war in order to address conflicting situations and challenges, highlighting the importance of fostering productive discourse and recognizing the fears and pain experienced by both sides.
The podcast delves into the challenges of expressing opinions about the Gaza conflict on social media, discussing the fear of backlash and the phenomenon of context collapse, while emphasizing the need to differentiate between legitimate criticism and oppression in order to allow diverse perspectives and foster meaningful dialogue.
Deep dives
The Ripple Effects of the War in Gaza
The podcast discusses the ripple effects of the war in Gaza and how it can manifest as conflicting situations in other parts of the world. It highlights incidents of violence, both physical and rhetorical, that have occurred as a result of the conflict. The speaker emphasizes the need for open dialogue and understanding, while also acknowledging the challenges in having nuanced conversations in the current polarized climate.
The Challenges of Speaking Out on Social Media
The podcast delves into the challenges of expressing opinions about the conflict on social media. It explores the fear of backlash, including the risk of being doxed or facing professional consequences. The speaker discusses the phenomenon of context collapse online, where discussions quickly get distorted and lead to adversarial interactions. They highlight the importance of fostering productive discourse and recognizing the fears and pain experienced by both sides.
Navigating the Silencing of Voices
The podcast examines the issue of silencing voices and the power dynamics at play. It mentions incidents where individuals were targeted for expressing their opinions, including removal of signs, harassment, and cancelation of speaking engagements. The speakers discuss the need to consider the context and differentiate between legitimate criticism and oppression. They emphasize the importance of allowing diverse perspectives and fostering meaningful dialogue while acknowledging the structural imbalances of power.
A Jewish writer and Muslim journalist sit down to discuss the power dynamics, tribalism, and role of empathy in a far-away conflict that hits close to home in America.
If you enjoy this show, please consider signing up for Slate Plus. Slate Plus members get benefits like zero ads on any Slate podcast, bonus episodes of shows like Slow Burn and Dear Prudence—and you’ll be supporting the work we do here on What Next. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to help support our work.