How choice can skew the public's understanding of what is real and what is fake
Aug 22, 2024
auto_awesome
David Rothschild, an economist at Microsoft Research and a contributor to the Media Bias Detector Project, dives into the complexities of media bias and its effects on public perception. He discusses the paradox of trust in mainstream media, where consumption persists despite declining trust levels. Rothschild examines how digital technology and the 24-hour news cycle have transformed journalism, exacerbating misinformation. He highlights the difficulties journalists face in maintaining neutrality in our polarized era and the urgent need for diverse voices to enrich media discourse.
The choices made by editors in mainstream media significantly shape public perception and contribute to the ongoing complexity of trust in news consumption.
The Media Bias Detector Project aims to track and analyze how different news outlets frame stories, influencing public understanding and discourse on important issues.
Deep dives
Understanding Media Bias and Consumer Trust
The podcast discusses the concept of media bias and highlights that the choices made by editors greatly influence public perception of news. David Rothschild emphasizes the importance of recognizing that the mainstream media still has a significant impact on consumers, despite the prevalent distrust. He points out that while surveys indicate low trust in mainstream media, many people continue to consume it, suggesting a complex relationship between trust and consumption. Moreover, Rothschild argues that the framing of news stories can affect people's understanding of important issues, as well as contribute to misinformation.
The Role of Media Bias Detector Project
The Media Bias Detector Project is introduced as a tool aimed at tracking and classifying top stories published by various news outlets across the political spectrum. Rothschild explains that the project seeks to provide insights into how different publications cover events, including what topics are chosen and how they are framed. This initiative stems from a desire to define the problem of media consumption rather than merely seeking solutions for misinformation. It ultimately aims to clarify how media choices impact public discourse and understanding of the world.
Shifts in Journalism and Audience Choices
The podcast delves into the shifts in journalism due to digital technology and social media, altering how news is covered and consumed. Rothschild highlights that the traditional model of journalism, which focused on delivering comprehensive updates, is being replaced by a demand-driven model. This shift leads to more fragmented news consumption, where audiences choose specific stories that align with their interests and values, often resulting in less exposure to diverse viewpoints. The discussion emphasizes that both the supply and demand sides of media consumption have evolved, leading to a more complex news landscape.
Impact of Algorithms and Disinformation
Rothschild addresses the role of algorithms in shaping media consumption and the prevalence of disinformation in the digital age. He suggests that while disinformation exists, it primarily affects a smaller audience that actively seeks out or is drawn toward dubious content. The focus, according to his research, should be on understanding the broader media diets of consumers, which often reflect a reliance on mainstream sources. Ultimately, the podcast encourages consideration of how different content choices and algorithmic influences affect public understanding and the choices people make in their media consumption.
David Rothschild, an economist at Microsoft Research, is one of the people behind the Media Bias Detector Project, which “Tracks and classifies the top stories published by a collection of prominent publishers spanning the political spectrum in close to real time.”
Visit the It's All Journalism website to find out how to subscribe to our podcast and weekly email newsletter.