Radically Genuine Podcast with Dr. Roger McFillin 213. "Psychiatry Is 90% a Scam" — A Psychiatrist Speaks Out
Jan 1, 2026
Dr. John Yaakov Guterson, known as 'The Singing Psychiatrist,' brings a fresh perspective to psychiatry, advocating for a soulful approach to mental health. He challenges the materialist view, emphasizing the importance of purpose and personal growth in understanding suffering. Guterson questions the validity of DSM labels and explores how despair can enrich human experience. He proposes integrating spirituality into medical care, suggesting daily practices like gratitude and mindfulness for holistic healing. The conversation dives deep into the intersection of mental health and the human spirit.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Soul Lost In A Checklist-Driven Psychiatry
- Modern psychiatry has reduced the human soul to a checklist of symptoms and a prescription pad.
- Roger McFillin argues this materialist view created an industry that numbs existential questions rather than heals them.
Training At A Leading Research Program
- John Yaakov Guterson describes training at Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic and feeling unsatisfied with its materialist answers.
- He began asking residents about the soul and later asked every patient about purpose instead of jumping to medication.
DSM Labels Oversimplify Human Complexity
- The DSM's many diagnostic labels oversimplify human complexity and miss the whole-person context.
- Guterson finds treating people as multifaceted souls yields better understanding than checklist diagnoses.