Freedomain with Stefan Molyneux 6215 Debate: Is Hitting Children Good?!?
18 snips
Dec 7, 2025 In a thought-provoking discussion, guest Malcolm Collins, a public commentator focused on parenting and education, argues in favor of limited physical discipline. He suggests that such methods can foster resilience in children and addresses their historical and cultural contexts. The conversation explores the balance between moral principles and practical parenting strategies, with Malcolm sharing personal anecdotes from his youth. Ultimately, both delve into the complexities of discipline, trauma, and the societal implications of parenting choices.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Non‑Aggression Principle Should Include Children
- Stefan Molyneux argues the non-aggression principle should protect children as the most vulnerable members of society.
- He claims power disparity raises moral obligation, so parents must not initiate force against children.
From Assumption To Reconsideration
- Malcolm Collins recounts his shift from assuming corporal punishment was wrong to reconsidering it after raising multiple children.
- He says physical boundaries sometimes stop dangerous behavior quickly and can be less harmful than emotional escalation.
Corporal Punishment As An Evolutionary Expectation
- Malcolm claims large, flourishing civilizations historically used corporal punishment and its removal correlates with youth mental-health issues.
- He interprets physical discipline as an evolved expectation in social mammals that builds resilience to negative stimuli.
