Dive into a thrilling comparison of two iconic Star Wars films! Discover how 'Rogue One' stands out with its intricate storytelling, while 'The Force Awakens' relies on nostalgia and familiar tropes. Unpack the emotional depth and character dynamics, as both hosts critique underdeveloped characters and simplistic backgrounds. They tackle the significance of kyber crystals and the quirky elements of space science, all while exploring the complexities of rebellion and identity in the galaxy far, far away.
The podcast critiques 'The Force Awakens' for its overreliance on fan service, which detracts from original storytelling and narrative cohesion.
While 'Rogue One' is praised for its unique war film approach, it suffers from muddled character development in its initial parts.
The discussion highlights the contrasting portrayals of the Force in both films, with 'Rogue One' achieving a more organic and subtle integration into the narrative.
Deep dives
Rogue One vs. The Force Awakens: Personal Preferences
The discussion compares 'Rogue One' and 'The Force Awakens,' with both speakers expressing a preference for 'Rogue One.' While they acknowledge that 'The Force Awakens' offers a classic hero's journey narrative, they critique its execution, noting various plot inconsistencies that detract from the viewing experience. The muddled character development in 'Rogue One' is highlighted, particularly in its first half, suggesting that it could have better established its ensemble cast. Furthermore, they appreciate 'Rogue One's' more unique approach as a war film, contrasting it with the adventure-driven plot of 'The Force Awakens.'
Soft Reboot and Fan Service Concerns
Both speakers explore the concept of 'The Force Awakens' as a soft reboot of the original Star Wars formula. They express concern that this approach felt too reliant on fan service rather than creating an original story that stands on its own. The presence of familiar elements and characters from the original trilogy is seen as a double-edged sword, where the nostalgia undermines innovative storytelling. They argue that while fan service has its place, it should not overshadow the need for solid narrative development.
Character Development Issues in The Force Awakens
The characters in 'The Force Awakens' are critiqued for lacking depth and development, particularly focusing on the protagonist Finn. They discuss the missed opportunities that arise from not exploring his background as a stormtrooper, which could have provided a richer narrative. Instead, Finn is portrayed as a somewhat simplistic character who does not grapple with the complexities of his past, diminishing his potential as a compelling figure. The need for morally ambiguous characters in the saga is emphasized, which they feel 'Rogue One' executed better than 'The Force Awakens.'
The Use of the Force in Both Movies
The representation and use of the Force in both films are analyzed, with a focus on inconsistencies and narrative convenience. In 'The Force Awakens,' the reliance on the Force to explain coincidences and plot points is criticized for undermining the story’s cohesion. Conversely, in 'Rogue One,' the Force is portrayed more subtly and organically within the narrative, enhancing the experience without overshadowing the characters. The balance of mystique surrounding the Force is mentioned as an important aspect that may have been mishandled in the later film.
The Role of Villains: Kylo Ren and Darth Vader
The antagonists in both films are examined, with particular attention to Kylo Ren’s characterization in 'The Force Awakens.' The frustration stems from viewing him as a poorly constructed villain whose actions do not align with intelligent decision-making, undermining his threat level. In contrast, the appearance of Darth Vader in 'Rogue One' is discussed as effective, particularly in his climactic scene that demonstrates his power. However, the speakers feel that certain villain interactions, such as the dialogue between Vader and Krennic, were unnecessary and detracted from Vader's intimidating persona.
This week, Daystar and Alexander do their first review by comparing the various rationalities and irrationalities of Star Wars: The Force Awakens and Rogue One, along with general things they liked and disliked about the movies.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
