Swethaa S. Ballakrishnen, "Accidental Feminism: Gender Parity and Selective Mobility Among India’s Professional Elite" (Princeton UP, 2021)
Jan 3, 2025
auto_awesome
Swethaa Ballakrishnen, an Assistant Professor of Law and a sociolegal scholar at UC Irvine, delves into the intriguing phenomenon of gender parity among India's elite professional circles. She discusses how the elite legal firms, despite being male-dominated, offer a surprising representation of women. Ballakrishnen explores the unexpected mechanisms behind this 'accidental feminism'—from gendered socialization to family support—contrasting it with women's struggles in consulting. Her insights challenge traditional narratives about progress and highlight the complexities of achieving real equality.
The concept of 'Accidental Feminism' illustrates how structural factors rather than explicit feminist agendas enable women's success in elite law firms.
Swetha Balakrishnan's research highlights the critical role of family and social networks in empowering women's professional advancement in law.
The discussion critiques the notion of meritocracy, revealing how it often obscures underlying inequalities tied to gender and class dynamics.
Deep dives
Professor Swetha Balakrishnan's Academic Journey
Professor Swetha Balakrishnan discusses her diverse academic background, which includes an undergraduate degree from NALSAR in India, followed by an LLM from Harvard and a PhD from Stanford. Her journey reflects a shift from law practice to academia, driven by a desire to engage with sociolegal scholarship. At Stanford, she honed her methodological skills and gained insights that significantly influenced her research interests, particularly in law, globalization, and gender from a feminist perspective. Her academic path showcases the importance of interdisciplinary approaches and varied educational experiences in shaping a scholar's research agenda.
Insights from 'Accidental Feminism'
The book 'Accidental Feminism' explores the intersection of gender and legal professions in India, particularly post-1991 economic liberalization. Swetha highlights the surprising gender parity and professional success experienced by women in elite corporate law firms, contrasting it with the persistent barriers in other sectors, like management consulting. These success stories challenge traditional narratives of gender inequality and reveal how structural changes in the profession have inadvertently benefited women. The book emphasizes the unexpected outcomes of globalization and legal reform, reshaping feminist discourse within the legal field.
The Role of Family and Social Networks
Swetha Balakrishnan emphasizes the significance of family and social networks in supporting women's professional journeys in law. Many successful women lawyers relied on kinship structures, especially in terms of caregiving, which allowed them to navigate work-life balance more effectively. This support network often includes lower-caste women providing domestic assistance, showcasing the layered complexities of gender and caste in professional settings. The book suggests that these familial and social arrangements play a crucial role in enabling women to thrive in their careers while also raising questions about the implications for traditional gender roles.
Meritocracy and Gender in the Legal Profession
Swetha discusses the notion of meritocracy within the context of women's advancement in the legal profession, particularly how it can sometimes mask underlying inequalities. Despite substantial achievements, the concept of merit is often tied to class and educational background, leading to a reinforcement of privilege rather than genuine equality. The women in her study often attribute their success to merit, downplaying the roles of gender dynamics and informal networks. This dichotomy raises questions about the true nature of equality in these elite settings and challenges traditional understandings of meritocracy in professional hierarchies.
Accidental Feminism as a Theoretical Framework
The concept of 'Accidental Feminism' serves as a key theoretical framework for understanding the unintentional progress and changes in gender dynamics within the Indian legal profession. Swetha argues that while these advancements may not be driven by explicitly feminist agendas, they nonetheless create opportunities for women in traditionally male-dominated spaces. This framing encourages a reevaluation of how social change occurs, highlighting the importance of context and unintended consequences. By positioning feminism as a process shaped by various factors rather than a goal, the book opens new avenues for scholarship and discussions around gender equality.
In India, elite law firms offer a surprising oasis for women within a hostile, predominantly male industry. Less than 10 percent of the country's lawyers are female, but women in the most prestigious firms are significantly represented both at entry and partnership. Elite workspaces are notorious for being unfriendly to new actors, so what allows for aberration in certain workspaces?
Drawing from observations and interviews with more than 130 elite professionals, Accidental Feminism: Gender Parity and Selective Mobility Among India’s Professional Elite(Princeton UP, 2021) examines how a range of underlying mechanisms-gendered socialization and essentialism, family structures and dynamics, and firm and regulatory histories-afford certain professionals egalitarian outcomes that are not available to their local and global peers. Juxtaposing findings on the legal profession with those on elite consulting firms, Swethaa Ballakrishnen reveals that parity arises not from a commitment to create feminist organizations, but from structural factors that incidentally come together to do gender differently. Simultaneously, their research offers notes of caution: while conditional convergence may create equality in ways that more targeted endeavors fail to achieve, "accidental" developments are hard to replicate, and are, in this case, buttressed by embedded inequalities. Ballakrishnen examines whether gender parity produced without institutional sanction should still be considered feminist.
In offering new ways to think about equality movements and outcomes, Accidental Feminism forces readers to critically consider the work of intention in progress narratives.
Noopur Raval is a postdoctoral researcher working at the intersection of Information Studies, STS, Media Studies and Anthropology.