Explore the historical treatments of mental health, including trepanation and the controversial methods of lobotomy and electroshock therapy. Learn about the transition from religious defect to medical condition and the introduction of The Lunacy Act in 1845. Dive into the rising awareness and reporting of mental health issues and the factors influencing modern mental health problems. Debate over the validity of the mental health crisis and contemplate Michel Foucault's quote on human behavior and consequences.
Throughout history, mental health treatments have ranged from primitive practices like trepanning to controversial methods like lobotomy and electroshock therapy.
The perception of mental health has evolved from religious defect to medical condition, but stigma and societal pressures still hinder progress in understanding and treating mental health issues.
Deep dives
A History of Mental Health: Trapanning and Beyond
Throughout history, mental health has been perceived in various ways. Trapanning, a surgical procedure that involved drilling a hole into the skull, was one of the earliest attempts at treating mental health issues. It was thought that by opening the skull, the cause of erratic behavior could be removed. This practice was widespread across different civilizations, including the recent case of a Dutch librarian in the 1960s. However, despite advancements in other areas of medicine, the treatment of mental health has not made significant progress. Reports estimate that 50% of the world's population will experience a mental health issue in their lifetime.
From Religious Defects to Medical Conditions
In the past, mental health problems were often associated with religious defects or moral failings. The Hippocratic idea of the four humors linked physical and mental health. However, these understandings were flawed. Treatment of mental health issues included burning people at the stake for witchcraft, chaining them up in asylums, and later, lobotomies and electroconvulsive therapy. The Lunacy Act in 1845 recognized mental illness as a health condition, but treatments remained problematic. Despite increased interest and research, the stigma around mental health hindered progress.
The Modern Mental Health Crisis
Today, mental health issues are more prevalent and affect certain demographic groups more than others. According to a recent survey, 20% of Americans currently live with a mental health issue, with higher rates among women and younger age groups. Various theories attempt to explain these trends, including social stigma, generational differences, cultural attitudes, and societal pressures. Some argue that more people are actually suffering from mental health issues, while others believe that the expanded definition of mental health and increased pharmaceutical treatments contribute to the perception of a crisis. The complex and nuanced nature of the debate calls for a comprehensive understanding of mental health in the 21st century.
Become a Pro Member and get “Students of Murder” course (normally €49) for free: https://bit.ly/Jan2025Offer
---
Mental health – it is a sensitive subject that affects every single one of us, with some of us struggling more than others.
In this episode, we are going to explore how mental health has been perceived throughout history and look at some of the reasons that led a top UN official to declare that we are living in a mental health crisis.
History of mental health treatments
Trepanning as an ancient "cure"
Transition from religious defect to medical condition
Grim conditions in early "mad houses"
Introduction of The Lunacy Act in 1845
Controversial treatments like lobotomy and electroshock therapy
Rising awareness and reporting of mental health issues
Factors influencing modern mental health problems
Debate over the validity of the mental health crisis
Michel Foucault's quote on human behavior and consequences