‘Donald Trump Is FDR’ | Interview: Batya Ungar-Sargon
May 5, 2025
auto_awesome
Batya Ungar-Sargon, a contributor to the Free Press and author of 'Second Class,' is a self-proclaimed “MAGA lefty” who defends Donald Trump's policies. She discusses her journey from leftist ideals to MAGA, emphasizing how Trump's early administration promoted working-class values. They explore the impact of tariffs likening them to a Swiss army knife for economic challenges, and touch on immigration policies and their repercussions. Batya's insights highlight the interplay between populism, the elite, and the working class in today's political landscape.
Batya Ungar-Sargon highlights her transition from leftist views to supporting Trump by emphasizing his pro-labor and anti-war positions.
The podcast discusses Trump's diplomatic foreign policy approach, advocating for non-interventionist strategies that prioritize American interests.
Concerns are raised about the implications of Trump's immigration policies on due process and America's image as a welcoming nation.
Deep dives
Return of Degree Cool Rush
Last year, Degree Cool Rush deodorant changed its formula, leading to significant backlash from consumers, including a petition by dissatisfied users. In response to this outcry, Degree acknowledged their error and decided to bring back the original Cool Rush scent, which retains its cool, crisp quality. This move was celebrated by fans of the product, as the original scent had been highly popular and considered a top choice in men's antiperspirants for the past decade. The deodorant is now available in major retailers such as Walmart and Target for under $4, rekindling the nostalgia and satisfaction of long-time users.
Thoughts on Trump's First 100 Days
The discussion highlights a lesser-explored viewpoint regarding Trump’s first 100 days, revealing that many supporters are hesitant to defend the president's agenda. The guest, Batya Ungar-Sargon, shares her perspective on how she transitioned from a more left-leaning stance to supporting MAGA, citing Trump's alignment with certain traditional leftist values, such as pro-labor positions and anti-war sentiments. She argues that his policies reflect a misunderstood approach that aims to prioritize working-class Americans, advocating for a realignment of political ideologies that fosters unity among the working class. This evolving political landscape indicates a shift in how supporters perceive Trump's impact on American democracy and the working populace.
Critique of Military Engagement
Trump's foreign policy approach, particularly regarding military engagements, diverges from traditional U.S. stances by advocating a more diplomatic, non-interventionist strategy. He emphasizes a reluctance to engage in wars that do not serve American interests, asserting that past conflicts, like those in Iraq and Afghanistan, have been misguided. The speaker interprets Trump's reluctance as a reflection of genuine concern for American lives and a desire to preserve resources rather than engage in unnecessary foreign conflicts. This perspective suggests that Trump's foreign policy could pave the way for a new era focused on diplomacy over military action without compromising national security.
Working-Class Representation
A critical analysis reveals that Trump's policies, particularly concerning tariffs and immigration, are intricately tied to the economic well-being of the working class. The discussion asserts that tariffs can be protective of American labor by resourcing jobs and reversing the trend of outsourcing that has negatively affected domestic manufacturing. However, this brings about the debate of increased prices for consumer goods as a trade-off for potential job growth and economic revitalization. Ultimately, the focus is on the need for politicians to prioritize the interests of the working class, addressing the structural inequities that have caused a decline in the American middle class’s prosperity.
Debate on Immigration Policies
The conversation also tackles the controversial immigration policies under Trump, including the abrupt changes that affect not just illegal immigrants but also tourists and legal visitors. Concerns are raised about the treatment of immigrants being sent back to potentially unsafe conditions in their home countries, which contradicts the principles of due process and humane treatment. The potential chilling effect on tourism reflects a broader concern about America's image as a welcoming nation, raising questions about the long-term impact on international relations. The discussion emphasizes the balance that needs to be struck between enforcing immigration laws and maintaining America’s commitment to humanitarian principles.
Discussion on Economic Policy
The dialogue transitions into economic strategies where there is a divide between populist economic ideals and traditional fiscal conservatism. Proposing higher taxes on the wealthy is reiterated as a means to bolster social welfare, yet it conflicts with the prevailing view that lower corporate tax rates incentivize growth. Critics of these populist ideas argue for sustainable practices that do not undermine traditional paths to prosperity while addressing income inequality. Ultimately, these discussions reveal a growing tension within political ideologies as they wrestle with new populist movements in understanding capitalism and social responsibility.
Jamie Weinstein is joined by self-proclaimed “MAGA lefty” Batya Ungar-Sargon to defend Donald Trump's first 100 days as president and explain how a "lefty" can be MAGA.
The Agenda: —Batya’s MAGA journey —MAGA Reaganites vs. MAGA lefties —Batya on The Fifth Column —Exporting American exceptionalism —Trump’s first 100 days —Trump’s meme coin —North Korea style worship —“Trump sees a tariff like a Swiss army knife.” —Immigration and due process
The Dispatch Podcast is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a non-partisan, conservative perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including members-only newsletters, bonus podcast episodes, and regular livestreams—click here.
