Downstream: This Is Why the Right Are Winning w/ Ash Sarkar
Feb 17, 2025
auto_awesome
Ash Sarkar, a prominent British left-wing journalist and author of 'Minority Rule', dives into the complexities of identity politics and its impact on progressive movements. She critiques how identity politics evolved from its anti-capitalist roots to a focus on individualism, questioning its effectiveness in fostering social change. Sarkar discusses the disconnect between elite education and working-class realities, alongside the media’s role in polarizing political discourse. With sharp insights, she addresses the challenges of navigating modern political landscapes and cultural movements.
Ash Sarkar argues that identity politics, though originally intended for empowerment, has paradoxically aided the consolidation of right-wing power.
She critiques the commodification of activism, emphasizing that media coverage often overshadows the need for substantial legislative change in social movements.
Sarka highlights the emotional challenges faced by political figures, advocating for resilience and supportive relationships in navigating public scrutiny.
Deep dives
The Emergence of Minority Rule
The discussion centers around the central theme of the concept of 'Minority Rule' as posed in Ash Sarka's debut book. Sarka argues that ideas initially cultivated by those on the left, relating to identity, meaning, and countering power dynamics, have paradoxically become tools for the right. This unexpected turn suggests that while these ideas aimed to empower marginalized groups, they have instead assisted right-wing factions in consolidating their economic and political influence. The realization sheds light on the ongoing struggle within political identity narratives and how they've been appropriated by opposing forces.
The Impact of Identity Politics
Sarka critically examines identity politics, describing it as a 'cage' that can limit collective action among people. She contends that while identity is integral to human understanding and social categorization, overemphasizing it fosters divisiveness rather than solidarity. The conversation suggests that neoliberalism has deepened this fracture by promoting individualism and competition among diverse identity groups. Consequently, Sarka encourages a re-evaluation of identity politics as a barrier to achieving larger common goals, particularly in the context of working-class solidarity.
Historical Context and Identity Politics
Sarka traces the origins of contemporary identity politics back to the 1960s and 1970s, attributing its rise to the societal movements of that era, which were marked by a stronger anti-capitalist sentiment. During this time, movements, such as those by the Combahee River Collective, viewed identity as a lens through which capitalist exploitation could be understood. However, as the political landscape evolved through the 1980s with the onset of neoliberalism, identity became increasingly commodified and focused on divisions rather than unity. Sarka argues that this shift has led the left to lose sight of its original mission of collective empowerment due to its fixation on individual identity politics.
The Role of Media and Cultural Narratives
The discussion highlights the transformative effect of media and cultural narratives on public perception and political mobilization. Sarka asserts that movements such as Black Lives Matter and Me Too, while successful in creating awareness, have not resulted in significant legislative changes. Instead, she critiques how these movements' success is often measured by media coverage and social media engagement, sidelining deeper material and structural issues. This commodification of activism through media illustrates the challenges faced by movements aiming for real change in a landscape dominated by superficial narratives.
Responding to Critique and Resistance
Sarka acknowledges that her examination of identity politics may provoke backlash, especially from those on the left who feel personally attacked. She describes navigating the tensions of critiquing a movement to which she belongs while advocating for necessary changes in its approach. This debate reveals an inherent struggle between the preservation of one's identity and the adaptability required to forge broader coalitions for change. Sarka emphasizes the need to reshape how discussions around identity politics are framed to foster understanding rather than division.
The Challenges of Political Engagement
In her reflections, Sarka touches upon the personal and professional challenges she faces in a politically charged environment, emphasizing how public scrutiny can fuel anxiety and doubt. The conversation explores the emotional toll that being a visible political figure entails, including experiencing hate and online harassment. Yet, she finds solace in her supportive relationships and community, crucial for maintaining resilience amid adversity. Ultimately, Sarka stresses the importance of emotional self-regulation and recognizing one's fears while remaining steadfast in one's political convictions.
“I’m literally a communist, you idiot”. For almost a decade Ash Sarkar has been one of Britain’s most prominent left wing political journalists. She first met Aaron Bastani in 2010, and was later invited on to the Novara FM podcast. It wasn’t long before she was calling Piers Morgan an idiot on morning TV. Now […]
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
