Journalist Nirupama Subramanian and Supreme Court advocate-on-record Anas Tanwir join the hosts to discuss the Pakistan elections, conspiracy theories surrounding American interference, revenue centralization in India, and the proposal for a common law in Uttarakhand. They also discuss the need for a public interest litigation to challenge the law and the impact of the Uniform Civil Code on Muslim women and men.
The protest in Ladakh highlights the centralized control of revenue and allocations by the BJP government, with the demand for constitutional safeguards and statehood for the union territory.
The proposed Uniform Civil Code in Uttarakhand sparks debate, with critics arguing that it cannot be hastily imposed without proper discussion and Muslim women should lead the conversation regarding personal laws.
Deep dives
Ladakh demands constitutional safeguards and statehood
In Ladakh, a complete shutdown was observed as thousands gathered to demand constitutional safeguards, protection of cultural identity, and statehood for the union territory. Since the revocation of Article 370 in 2019, Ladakh lost special privileges and power. However, the center has been taking over land and major demands include inclusion in the six schedule to make their own laws. This protest, overlooked by mainstream media, highlights the centralized control of revenue and allocations by the BJP government.
Pakistan elections and the potential impact of Nawaz Sharif
The Pakistan elections feature three major parties: the Pakistan Muslim League, Tehreek-e-Insaf, and the Pakistan People's Party. The cutting off of internet and telecommunication services aims to prevent a high voter turnout, which was expected to favor PTI. While PTI is not running as a party, Nawaz Sharif's potential return as Prime Minister may bring a thaw in icy relations with India. Sharif has advocated for good friendly ties and the army has recently expressed a focus on geoeconomics. A renewed Pakistan-India relationship could be driven by economic concerns and the need for trade.
Uttarakhand's proposed Uniform Civil Code (UCC) has sparked debate. Critics argue that the UCC, which is not actually 'common' due to various exemptions, cannot be hastily imposed without proper discussion. Some see it as an attempt to control the personal lives of citizens, while others view it as targeting specific communities. The conversation around personal laws should be led by Muslim women as it directly impacts them, particularly regarding the polygamous practice. However, it is disingenuous to claim that the discourse should be solely shaped by Hindu men when discussing Muslim women's perspectives.
This week, Newslaundry’s Manisha Pande, Raman Kirpal and Jayashree Arunachalam are joined by journalist Nirupama Subramanian and Supreme Court advocate-on-record Anas Tanwir.
Check out the Newslaundry store and flaunt your love for independent media.