The Big Five Podcast A Quebec judge says ‘Netflix’ sentences aren’t sentences at all. Plus: Another brewing IT scandal for the Quebec government.
Jul 21, 2025
Join Jonathan Kalles, a former advisor to PM Justin Trudeau, and Catherine Hogan, a high school teacher, as they tackle serious issues facing Quebec. They discuss a judge's controversial ruling on drunk driving sentences, questioning the effectiveness of current punishments. The duo also shines a light on rising crime and drug use in Montreal's neighborhoods, reflecting on community concerns and law enforcement's role. They dive into the accountability of the Quebec government over costly IT projects, sparking lively debate on urban challenges.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Catherine's Monster Ride Tale
- Catherine Hogan shared a personal experience riding La Monster at La Ronde that resulted in lasting back pain.
- She has avoided roller coasters entirely since that traumatic teenage experience.
'Netflix Sentences' Not Real Punishment
- Judge Denis Galiazatos rejects house arrest with conveniences as a true sentence for drunk driving offenders.
- A year in jail sends a stronger message about consequences than a comfortable home sentence.
Use Sentencing to Set Precedents
- Judges should use sentencing to set clear precedents that communicate consequences effectively.
- Strong messages through sentencing can influence public perception and deter crime.