ChatGPT vs Gemini For Studying and Learning (Ep. 527)

Aug 12, 2025

Explore the evolving world of AI tutoring with insights into ChatGPT’s Study and Learn mode and Gemini’s Guided Learning. Discover how these tools facilitate personalized education through Socratic-style teaching. Learn about the unique capabilities of Notebook LM in organizing resources and creating study guides. Listen to stories of custom AI tutor creations, addressing the misconception that AI learning is cheating. Uncover the user experience differences and the need for teaching prompt-writing skills to harness AI effectively.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

ANECDOTE

Built An Algebra II Tutor For His Daughter

Brian set up an Algebra II tutor for his daughter on her first day of high school to support personalized learning.
He used custom GPT prompts and resources so she could learn at her own pace and style.

INSIGHT

Socratic Teaching Is Central To New Modes

Study and Learn (ChatGPT) and Guided Learning (Gemini) both use Socratic-style teaching to avoid simply giving answers.
Their goal is to build comprehension and retention, not to do homework for the learner.

ADVICE

Start With A Hierarchical Taxonomy

Create a hierarchical taxonomy of subjects and break topics into atomic lessons before generating AI courses.
Use that taxonomy to sequence digestible lessons so learners can progress through a full syllabus.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

The Daily AI Show takes a deep look at AI tutoring, comparing ChatGPT’s Study and Learn mode, Google’s Gemini Guided Learning, and Notebook LM. The discussion covers how these tools change the way people of all ages can learn, from traditional K–12 students to lifelong learners. The team shares personal stories, live demos, and practical advice on building custom AI tutors for highly personalized education.

Key Points Discussed

• ChatGPT’s Study and Learn mode and Gemini’s Guided Learning both use Socratic-style teaching, but differ in pacing, interactivity, and ability to generate visuals.

• Notebook LM stands out for organizing diverse resources into a single knowledge base, creating study guides, and generating mind maps.

• Brian shows how he built a custom Algebra II tutor for his daughter using optimized prompts, YouTube transcripts, and tailored analogies.

• AI tutors can adjust to different learning styles, making education more efficient and personalized.

• Discussion on the ethical misconception that AI tutoring is “cheating” and why efficiency and comprehension should be the focus.

• Differences in user experience between ChatGPT and Gemini, including Gemini’s smaller, more manageable lesson chunks versus ChatGPT’s richer but denser responses.

• Notebook LM’s strengths for both academic and business learning use cases, including rapid onboarding to new concepts.

• Importance of teaching prompt-writing skills alongside subject knowledge to prepare students for working with AI tools in the future.

• Potential for AI tutors to adapt content based on student interests, increasing engagement and retention.

Timestamps & Topics

00:00:00 🎓 Why AI tutoring is an education inflection point

00:02:05 💡 Tools in focus: ChatGPT Study and Learn, Gemini Guided Learning, Notebook LM

00:06:28 🧮 Brian’s Algebra II tutor build for his daughter

00:10:23 🗂️ Andy explains taxonomy and AI course creation with Sensei

00:14:04 🛠️ Addressing “cheating” concerns and improving efficiency in learning

00:18:44 📚 Personalizing content to individual learning needs

00:22:59 🧩 Using analogies, storytelling, and tailored prompts for better comprehension

00:28:27 📊 Demo of Algebra II tutoring in ChatGPT

00:34:25 ✏️ Gemini Guided Learning demo and differences from ChatGPT

00:37:29 ⚖️ Matching tools to learner style for best results

00:42:03 🔍 Deep dive into personalized education potential

00:46:52 🖼️ Future of AI tutors with interactive visuals and games

00:49:38 🗣️ Teaching prompt skills alongside subject learning

00:51:29 🗄️ Business use case demo with Notebook LM and “Checklist Manifesto”

00:55:57 🎯 Applying AI tutoring methods beyond school subjects

00:58:02 🤝 Invitation to join the Slack community for deeper training

Hashtags

#AITutoring #AIinEducation #ChatGPT #Gemini #NotebookLM #StudyAndLearn #GuidedLearning #CustomGPT #DailyAIShow #EdTech #PersonalizedLearning

The Daily AI Show Co-Hosts:

Andy Halliday, Beth Lyons, Brian Maucere, Eran Malloch, Jyunmi Hatcher, and Karl Yeh