Long Reads: The German Peasants' War w/ Martin Empson
Oct 24, 2024
auto_awesome
In this engaging discussion, Martin Empson, a writer and historian about to release his book on the German Peasants' War, dives into this pivotal uprising. He highlights how the Reformation ignited popular resistance against feudalism. The conversation unveils the complex socio-economic divides of pre-Reformation Germany, Martin Luther's pivotal influence, and how he ultimately sided with the ruling class despite initial sympathy for the peasants. Empson also explores the lasting legacies of this revolt in shaping revolutionary thought and class struggle.
The German Peasants' War represented the largest social revolt in pre-French Revolution Europe, highlighting deep-seated grievances against feudalism.
Martin Luther's critique of the Catholic Church galvanized support and played a pivotal role in the growing rift within German society.
The 12 Articles articulated practical demands of the peasants, reflecting their aspirations for local autonomy and a fairer society amidst repression.
Deep dives
Context of Change in Early 16th Century Germany
In the early 16th century, Germany was experiencing significant social and economic transformations influenced by urban growth and emerging merchant classes. About 80-85% of the population were peasants, who faced exploitation under feudal laws, which were increasingly conflicting with the interests of a burgeoning bourgeois class seeking profit. These tensions led to a societal fracture highlighted by waves of local revolts and the eventual emergence of widespread discontent. By 1524, this discontent culminated in the German Peasants' War, signifying a major uprising against entrenched feudal structures.
Martin Luther's Role in the Reformation
Martin Luther emerged as a pivotal figure in the Reformation by critiquing the Catholic Church's practices, particularly the selling of indulgences, through his 95 Theses. His ideas not only resonated with discontented individuals across social strata but also fueled wider debates about religious authority and individual faith. Initially underestimated by the elite, Luther effectively mobilized public support, which eventually led the church to issue a papal bull demanding his recantation. Luther’s refusal and public burning of this decree exacerbated the church's crisis and highlighted the growing rift within German society.
Outbreak and Dynamics of the Peasants' War
The Peasants' War, breaking out in 1524, became the largest social uprising in Europe prior to the French Revolution, driven by years of underlying grievances. Peasant armies, composed of hundreds of thousands, were formed to confront local lords and royal authority, fueled by various triggers representing broader discontent. Documented testimonies from peasants, particularly the 12 Articles, articulated their frustrations over high taxes, land enclosures, and the church's oppressive practices. While these revolts demonstrated rampant dissatisfaction, they were ultimately met with brutal suppression from the feudal powers.
Significance of the 12 Articles
The 12 Articles, originating from meetings among rebel leaders, were crucial in conveying the collective demands of the peasantry during the revolt. These articles outlined grievances such as excessive taxation and a call for local control over clergy, reflecting aspirations for a fairer society. Rather than a revolutionary manifesto, the articles were rooted in practical demands driven by the lived experiences of the peasants, suggesting pathways toward reducing oppression. Their proposals also included opportunities for local autonomy, highlighting a desire for self-determination amid oppressive feudal structures.
Long-term Legacy of the Peasants' War
Despite the defeat of the Peasants' War, its legacy persisted in shaping the socio-political landscape of Germany and inspiring future generations of radicals. The uprising instilled fear among the ruling classes, influencing monarchs across Europe to temper peasant discontent preemptively. Ultimately, the failed revolt delayed the development of a bourgeois society in Germany, maintaining the influence of the aristocracy and stunting social progress. Furthermore, the Peasants' War positioned figures like Thomas Munzer as symbols of revolutionary yearning, linking movements from the Reformation period to later socialist ideologies.
The German Peasants’ War was the biggest social revolt in a European country during the period before the French Revolution. In the wake of the Reformation, a movement among the popular classes rose up against feudalism and aristocratic power. The revolt was brutally crushed and the challenge to the feudal order was defeated. Marxist writers like Friedrich Engels and Karl Kautsky later made it into a key reference point for their theories of class struggle.
Long Reads is joined by the writer and historian Martin Empson to discuss the rebellion. His book on the topic, The Time of the Harvest Has Come, will soon be published.
Long Reads is a Jacobin podcast looking in-depth at political topics and thinkers, both contemporary and historical, with the magazine’s longform writers. Hosted by features editor Daniel Finn. Produced by Conor Gillies, music by Knxwledge.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode