‘Professors are the enemy’: Trump’s war on higher education
Mar 26, 2025
auto_awesome
Joseph Howley, a Professor of Classics at Columbia University, offers keen insights into the escalating conflict between higher education and political forces. He discusses Trump's $400 million funding withdrawal from Columbia due to alleged anti-Semitism and the implications for academic freedom. The chilling climate of fear among professors echoes McCarthyism, as dissenting voices are stifled. Howley also addresses the university's response to protests linked to the Gaza crisis, highlighting the dangerous impact of political interference.
The podcast highlights the tension between student activism and university authorities, marked by police raids that instilled fear among protesting students.
It addresses the politicization of campus dialogues surrounding Israel and Palestine, where accusations of anti-Semitism are used to suppress dissent and undermine academic freedoms.
Deep dives
The Impact of Campus Protests
In the wake of the conflict in Gaza, student protests erupted across campuses, including Columbia University, where students demanded divestment from Israel. These protests transformed into encampments, symbolizing a space for solidarity and community amid tumultuous political sentiments. Some faculty members expressed their support for the activists, framing their efforts as necessary for raising awareness about Palestinian struggles. However, the intensity of these protests raised concerns about potential repercussions for the students involved, leading to a significant clash between student activists and university authorities.
Police Raids and Their Consequences
The university's response to the encampments included aggressive police action, with raids conducted to dismantle student gatherings. This marked a significant shift in the campus dynamic, as police are seldom called upon for such actions. Faculty members decried the police presence, suggesting it violated Columbia's values that prioritize free speech and peaceful demonstration. The police raids not only addressed the encampments but also instilled fear among students, heightening the stakes of expressing dissent on campus.
The Narrative of Anti-Semitism
Amid the protests, an allegation of rising anti-Semitism on campuses fueled tensions as conservative political figures labeled activism against Israel as inherently anti-Jewish. This narrative has contributed to the perception of an unsafe environment for Jewish students, yet many argue it misrepresents the complexities of campus dialogues surrounding Israel and Palestine. The response to these claims often manifests in punitive measures against perceived dissent, including the establishment of anti-Semitism task forces lacking diverse perspectives. Critics argue that this framing serves as a political tool for undermining academic freedoms rather than addressing legitimate concerns about harassment.
Government Targeting and Institutional Fear
Federal scrutiny of students involved in protests has heightened concerns over civil liberties, with reports of immigration agents targeting individuals based on their activism. This occurred alongside the administration's overt threats to cut funding to universities perceived as unwilling to suppress dissent. The fear of being targeted for activism has led some students to leave the country, while those remaining express anxiety about their safety and future. This climate of fear is exacerbated by the silence from university administrations, which has failed to provide adequate protections for affected students.
In a 2021 speech entitled ‘The Universities are the enemy,’ Vice President JD Vance laid out a plan for America’s universities saying in part “we have to honestly and aggressively attack the universities in this country.”
Columbia University has become ground zero for the Trump administration's war on higher education. Following a year of pro-Palestinian protest on campus, Trump revoked $400-million in funding and has instructed federal agents to oversee raids on campus, looking to deport international students and permanent residents that have been involved in protest.
Joseph Howley is a professor at Columbia and joins the show to discuss the last year and a half on campus, at a time students are being hunted, and some feel the university has capitulated to the demands of a hostile government.