This episode dives into the hefty settlement Disney's ABC faced over controversial remarks linking Trump to criminal behavior. Legal complexities surround presidential immunity and its implications on Trump's court outcomes. Flynn's failed defamation case against Wilson showcases the tricky line between personal attacks and political speech. Tensions escalate with a healthcare threat incident, while Biden's commutations spark debates on criminal justice reform. The discussion also touches on the fraught concepts of punishment and rehabilitation in an evolving legal landscape.
Judge Mershon's ruling emphasizes that personal communications, even from a president, do not qualify for immunity, maintaining legal accountability.
The substantial $15 million settlement between Trump and ABC highlights his contentious relationship with media outlets amidst ongoing defamation claims.
The podcast speculates on the complex future of Trump's legal cases as political contexts may influence judicial proceedings for sitting presidents.
Deep dives
Judge Mershon's Ruling on Trump's Conviction
Judge Mershon ruled against a motion to dismiss the convictions of Donald Trump on charges of falsifying business records, despite Trump's team citing presidential immunity. The judge clarified that certain evidence presented during the trial, including communications with White House staff, pertained to private matters rather than official presidential acts, thereby not qualifying for immunity protections. He emphasized the timing of Trump's objections, indicating they were not raised in a timely manner. Ultimately, the judge deemed the evidence strong enough to uphold the convictions, indicating that the core legal principles remained intact.
The Question of Presidential Immunity
The podcast delves into the implications of the Supreme Court's ruling on presidential immunity and its effect on ongoing criminal prosecutions of former presidents. The discussion highlights the complexities of how actions taken by a president can blur legal boundaries when evaluating what constitutes evidence. Judge Mershon noted that presidential communications involving personal matters do not fall under the immunity umbrella, allowing relevant evidence to be presented at trial. The analysis raises questions around how presidential actions are interpreted legally and whether these rulings may lead to future complications in similar cases.
Harmless Error Doctrine in Presidential Cases
Judge Mershon also referenced the 'harmless error' doctrine concerning the use of evidence that may later be deemed inadmissible due to presidential immunity. He argued that even if the introduction of certain evidence was a mistake, it did not alter the overall outcome of the trial, which was based on strong evidence against Trump. The discussion touches on the complexities of applying this doctrine, especially regarding the unique legal protections afforded to presidential acts. The result suggests a tension between preserving the integrity of presidential duties while addressing potential legal violations in office.
Implications of Ongoing Criminal Cases
There is speculation regarding the future of Trump's ongoing legal cases, particularly in relation to his potential presidency. The podcast discusses whether cases could be suspended while he serves as president, reflecting a broader legal precedent that has emerged surrounding the prosecution of sitting presidents. The commentary suggests that Judge Mershon may lean towards dismissal during Trump's presidency while still ensuring that the legal process adheres to established laws. This creates a scenario where justice is questioned in the political context, significantly affecting how cases against politicians proceed.
Trump's Defamation Lawsuits Against Media
The episode discusses Trump's recent settlement with ABC News, stemming from defamation allegations regarding comments made during an interview about the E. Jean Carroll verdict. The substantial settlement, amounting to $15 million, raises questions about the motivations behind such a payment, suggesting that ABC may have wished to avoid prolonged litigation and potential reputational damage. The discussion contrasts this case with Trump's other lawsuits, showcasing his litigious approach against media figures where he believes he has been wronged. The conversation concludes with the implications of Trump's legal actions for press freedoms and reporting standards in politically charged environments.
This is our last episode of 2024! We'll be back right after the new year to discuss new messes. Today, we look at the substantial settlement that Disney-owned ABC has agreed to pay over George Stephanopoulos’s repeated assertions that Donald Trump had been found “liable for rape” by a jury or juries. And Trump sues CBS, Ann Selzer and the Des Moines Register. Plus: Judge Juan Merchan has ruled that the Supreme Court decision establishing a sphere of presidential immunity does not compromise the guilty verdicts Trump faced in his court — we discuss the reasons. Meanwhile, Mike Flynn has lost an incompetently-litigated defamation case against Rick Wilson; a Blue Cross customer faces criminal charges for telling a call center worker “you people are next” in an argument over a claim denial; and Ingrid Lewis-Martin, Eric Adams’ longtime right-hand woman, continues to find ways to annoy Ken by not shutting up about her impending criminal charges.
Visit serioustrouble.show to support the show and to find a transcript of this episode.
This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.serioustrouble.show/subscribe
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode