The lack of shade in Los Angeles is a pressing issue that disproportionately affects marginalized communities, exacerbating existing social disparities and limiting the comfort and safety of vulnerable individuals.
Efforts to address the shade problem in Los Angeles face challenges such as ADA compliance regulations, lack of coordination among different agencies, and limitations posed by sidewalk design and limited real estate.
Deep dives
Lack of Shade in Los Angeles: A Hot Button Issue
Los Angeles is facing a shade problem, with unequal distribution of shade and limited access to shade in public spaces. Shade is crucial for human comfort and protection, especially in hot, arid environments like Los Angeles. The city's design, focusing on wide sidewalks and green spaces in wealthier neighborhoods, leads to unequal shade distribution. Lack of density and anti-density sentiments deter the creation of shaded public spaces. Additionally, redevelopment and the dominance of cars in the city have resulted in the removal of shade-providing trees. Efforts to address the issue, such as installing shade structures at bus stops, face challenges due to regulations, ADA compliance, and lack of coordination among different agencies. Although critics expressed disappointment with the design of Las Ambrita, a shade structure installed in Los Angeles, any shade is seen as an improvement considering the magnitude of the shade problem in the city.
Impact of Shade Inequity on Citizens
The lack of shade in Los Angeles has a significant impact on its citizens. Without access to shade, individuals can experience heat-related illnesses, discomfort, and even danger, especially vulnerable groups such as the elderly, obese, and pregnant individuals. Shade inequality is also a matter of social equity, as access to shade is often linked to socioeconomic factors. Affluent neighborhoods have wider sidewalks and greater tree canopy, while marginalized communities lack these amenities. The inequitable distribution of shade exacerbates existing social disparities and further limits the comfort and safety of those who rely on public spaces, such as bus riders.
Barriers to Creating Shade in Los Angeles
Multiple barriers hinder the creation of shade in Los Angeles. ADA compliance regulations require clear space for accessibility, which limits the available space for shade structures. Sidewalk design and limited real estate pose additional challenges. Different agencies responsible for public spaces in the city often work independently, lacking coordination and collaboration. Sidewalk width narrows in neighborhoods with higher populations of people of color, further reducing space for shading. Infrastructure such as overhead power lines and driveways also prevent the planting of shade trees or building shade structures. These constraints contribute to the difficulty of implementing effective shade solutions in the city.
Informal Urbanism and Shade Solutions
Informal urbanism efforts by residents, particularly in Latino neighborhoods, demonstrate the community's resourcefulness in creating solutions for shade. People install makeshift shade structures, such as shade sails and tarps, in their yards or on their properties to provide relief from the sun. However, translating these grassroots efforts into public spaces faces hurdles. Regulations and city control hinder the installation of such structures on sidewalks or in other public areas. The fear of fines and obstruction regulations prevent more widespread grassroots urbanism initiatives. Encouraging and supporting community-driven shade solutions could be a step towards addressing the shade problem in Los Angeles.
This past May, the city of Los Angeles rolled out a brand new, state-of-the art feature for bus shelters. It’s called La Sombrita. La Sombrita is a metal screen that’s intended to provide shade for the thousands of people who ride the bus every day. The shade screen is about two feet wide, ten feet tall, and it kinda looks like a curved teal metal surfboard filled with tiny holes. Right away, Angelinos were not happy. This heated conversation got us thinking about our interview with Sam Bloch about inequality and shade and we asked Sam back to get thoughts about La Sombrita, and whether the controversial shade sail could actually be a good thing for shade-starved Angelinos.