Reflecting on the tumultuous events of 2020, the podcast delves into the anti-democratic and revanchist nature of the Right in the US. Topics include downplaying the pandemic, exacerbating anxieties over police violence, and supporting Trump's election conspiracy. The hosts explore the intersection of class and culture wars, the prioritization of profits over public health, and the challenges to democracy posed by the Republican Party's populist shift.
Read more
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The pandemic exposed the flaws in right-wing ideology, highlighting the lack of state capacity and fear of accountability.
The right's support for police violence and disdain for democratic accountability underscores their fear of disorder and weak state oversight.
The rejection of liberalism by the right signifies a departure from equal rights and embraces political conflict over neutral spaces for debate.
Deep dives
The Year's Culmination: Pandemic and Political Unrest
The podcast episode delves into how the events of 2020, characterized by the pandemic and political unrest, have intertwined to reflect a broader societal reflection. The response to the pandemic showcased the bankruptcy of right-wing ideology, revealing absences in state capacity and an overarching fear of state accountability. Simultaneously, the uprisings against police violence highlighted the excesses of state power, contrasting the right's support for police violence with their disdain for democratic accountability in state functions.
Conservative Ideals and Responses: Fear of Disorder and State Capacity
The conservative movement's response to the uprisings and pandemic underscores their deep-seated fears of disorder and a lack of state capacity under democratic oversight. Ideologically, the right supports state power wielded through violence, as evidenced by their staunch pro-police stance, while rejecting state capacity that is democratically accountable or beneficial for public welfare.
Electoral Politics and Leftist Uprisings: Intersections and Missed Connections
The discussion extends to the relationship between leftist uprisings, demands by social movements, and electoral politics. It highlights that leftist movements aim for broader societal change beyond electoral victories, emphasizing the multi-faceted strategies and goals of grassroots movements compared to electoral campaigns. The intersection of these dynamics reflects a larger narrative of fragility, vulnerability, and solidarity in progressive movements.
Critique of Liberalism by the Right
The rejection of liberalism by the right implies a dismissal of equality and individual rights inherent in democratic systems. It signals a departure from the belief in equal rights and equal say in a political community. By shifting away from liberal principles, the right advocates for a view that deems the political landscape as a war of values, negating the presence of neutral political spaces for debate and democratic decision-making.
Diverging Critiques of Liberalism by Left and Right
The left criticizes liberalism on the grounds that it fails to provide equal opportunities for all individuals to participate meaningfully in democracy, calling for redistribution of power. In contrast, the right's criticism of liberalism centers on the feared outcomes it may produce, reflecting concerns that liberalism threatens specific moral preoccupations and societal values. The left seeks liberalism to fulfill its promises through economic democracy, while the right contends that liberalism leads to unfavorable results and challenges the legitimacy of democratic processes.
Matt and Sam—in a rare, just-the-two-of-them episode—look back at what a bad year revealed about a number of bad people, especially the coterie of rightwing intellectuals and politicians who have downplayed the pandemic, exacerbated anxieties about the uprising against police violence, and played along with Donald Trump's conspiracy-fueled attempts to steal the presidential election. What holds these efforts together, and what do they say about the state of conservatism? It turns out that 2020 confirmed the anti-democratic, revanchist character of the Right in the United States.