In this engaging conversation, Amberly McAteer, a parenting columnist for The Globe and Mail, dives into the issue of overscheduling kids. She reveals how an overloaded schedule can lead to heightened anxiety and depression in children. With insights into the historical pressures parents face, Amberly advocates for the importance of downtime and family time. She also discusses practical strategies for recognizing and managing overscheduling, emphasizing that quality family interactions, like shared meals, enhance children's development over a packed activity calendar.
Overscheduling kids can lead to negative mental health outcomes, highlighting the importance of balancing structured activities with downtime.
Experts emphasize the value of unstructured family time, which fosters essential life skills and contributes positively to children's future success.
Deep dives
Understanding Overscheduling
Overscheduling refers to the feeling of being stretched too thin, which can manifest in both parents and children feeling overwhelmed by numerous activities. Many parents, like the one mentioned in the podcast, find their children enrolled in multiple extracurriculars, sometimes leading to stress rather than enrichment. An example discussed involved a five-year-old balancing five different activities, where the child expressed her dislike of the rushed pace over her love for ballet, highlighting the awareness children can have about their limits. Recognizing this feeling of stress is crucial for families to evaluate the balance of activities in their lives.
Impact on Mental Health
Research shows a potential link between overscheduling children and negative outcomes like anxiety and depression. A study published in 2024 indicated that excessive enrichment activities could relate to lower well-being scores in children, suggesting that the pressure of constant engagement might affect their mental health. Additionally, psychologists emphasize that not all activities contribute equally to a child's development; those based on social interaction and collaboration tend to be more beneficial than solitary activities. Such insights call for communities to reconsider their expectations of structured activities in favor of more balanced approaches.
The Need for Balance
Finding a balance between structured activities and downtime is essential for both kids and parents. The pressure to keep children busy is often exacerbated by social media and peer comparisons, leading parents to inadvertently overcommit their kids. Experts advocate for families to prioritize unstructured time together, such as having family dinners, which have been shown to significantly correlate with children's future success. Embracing flexibility in family schedules allows for quality time and fosters important life skills that structured activities may not provide.
When it comes to enrolling your kids in extracurricular activities, how many is too many? Is there such a thing as over-scheduling your kids? Parenting experts say ‘yes,’ and that doing so can have long-term negative effects on your children.
Amberly McAteer is a contributing columnist for The Globe and Mail who recently looked into what the research says about programming activities for your kids, how long we’ve been ignoring expert advice, and what it means for their well-being.