The Charlie Kirk Show The Debate Heard Around the World
Jul 15, 2025
In a fiery debate, stand-up comedian and libertarian Dave Smith clashes with Newsweek columnist Josh Hammer over the Israel-U.S. relationship at the Student Action Summit. They tackle hot-button issues like Iran's nuclear threat, military interventions, and the influence of AIPAC in U.S. foreign policy. Smith advocates for a non-interventionist stance while Hammer defends Israel's role and criticizes critics of U.S. support. The discussion offers a deep dive into the complexities of ethical warfare and the responsibilities surrounding ongoing conflicts in the Middle East.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Neocons and Middle East Wars
- Dave Smith described America’s repeated wars as militarism hijacked by neoconservatives linked to Israeli interests.
- He referenced plans revealed by General Wesley Clark to overthrow seven countries, culminating with Iran.
Iran Nuclear Threat Discussion
- Josh Hammer acknowledged uncertainty on Iran’s nuclear threat but noted decades of attempts to acquire nuclear weapons.
- He cited IAEA warnings about Iran blocking inspections and enriching uranium suspiciously fast.
Core Divide on Israel and U.S.
- The debate reveals deep disagreements on Israel being a U.S. ally and the extent of its influence on American politics.
- Those who oppose American military involvement urge a return to constitutional republic principles and fiscal responsibility.
