The Atheist Experience 27.33 08-20-2023 with Armin Navabi and Dave Warnock
Aug 21, 2023
auto_awesome
Renowned atheist activist and author Armin Navabi and ex-pastor Dave Warnock discuss the limited understanding of creation in the Quran and Bible, arguments for and against reincarnation, the relationship between Abraham's sons in different religious traditions, the fine-tuning argument for the existence of God, and the existence and nature of God. They also announce a new podcast channel, invite theists to defend Islam, and share personal stories about their journey to atheism.
The fine-tuning argument for the existence of an intelligent designer is flawed due to its reliance on human-centric perspectives and limited understanding of the universe, as well as its failure to explain the origin of the supposed intelligent designer.
The importance of evidence and scientific study is emphasized in validating claims of supernatural abilities, with extraordinary claims requiring extraordinary evidence.
Deep dives
The Fine-Tuning Argument for the Existence of God
The fine-tuning argument claims that the existence of a life-permitting universe is unlikely if naturalism is true, but likely if theism is true. It suggests that the various constants and initial conditions of our universe are so precisely arranged that they support the idea of an intelligent designer. However, this argument relies on the assumption that our universe is unlikely under naturalism, which is not necessarily true, as it is based on human-centric perspectives and our limited understanding of the universe. It also fails to address the criticisms that arise concerning the interpretation and usage of probability, as well as modal claims. The argument presents more questions than answers, as it does not explain how or why the supposed intelligent designer came to be, leaving more mysteries in its wake than the purported fine-tuning it attempts to explain.
Becoming an Atheist Due to the Indifference of God towards Human Suffering
The caller, Judy, shares her unique experience of becoming an atheist at a young age due to her disappointment in God's indifference towards human suffering. She recalls being raised as a Jehovah's Witness and learning about the story of the flood, which led her to despise God for the immense suffering inflicted upon humanity. She decided to pretend, act good, and stand in front of God one day only to spit in his eye as a final act. Now as an atheist, she expresses her disdain for claims of a god being involved in people's lives when there is no evidence to support it.
Questioning the Validity of Supernatural Abilities
Judy shares her experiences of seemingly having the ability to sense illness or issues in people's bodies without prior knowledge. However, she acknowledges that such abilities are highly unlikely and is open to the idea that there might be natural explanations for these experiences. Armin and Dave emphasize the importance of evidence and scientific study in validating claims of supernatural abilities, noting that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
Admiration for Armin's Label of Bible Concubines as Sex Slaves
Judy expresses her appreciation for Armin's description of concubines in the Bible as sex slaves, as this accurately reflects the reality of their situation. She criticizes the lack of attention given to this aspect of slavery in religious discussions, highlighting the mistreatment of these women as they were subject to physical abuse by their masters and wives. Judy shares her perspective on the horror of such practices and the need for honest conversations about the negative aspects of religion.