The Inside Story Podcast How far will the US go in defending Tel Aviv?
Sep 11, 2025
Glenn Carle, a former CIA officer, and Hassan Mneimneh, a Middle East scholar, delve into the complexities of U.S.-Israel relations. They discuss the U.S.'s unwavering support for Israel despite rising global accusations against its actions in Gaza. Carle and Mneimneh analyze Netanyahu's political maneuvers amid changing administrations and public opinion. They also explore strategic reasons behind the alliance, how it shapes American politics, and whether this support truly fosters peace or heightens regional tensions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
US Priority: Guaranteeing Israel's Survival
- The U.S. has long prioritized guaranteeing Israel's national survival as a top Middle East policy objective.
- Glenn Carle argues this historical priority shapes U.S. actions even when facts suggest distancing might be wise.
Biden Versus Trump: Different Degrees Of Backing
- Carle says Biden did not give Netanyahu an unconditional carte blanche like Trump's administration did.
- He stresses American administrations differ in frustration and constraints despite shared commitment to Israel's security.
Support Runs Deep And Enables Avoidance
- Hassan Mneimneh argues U.S. support predates recent administrations and has ideological roots going back to Truman.
- He contends U.S. policy enables Israeli avoidance of resolving the Palestinian question.