Mohammed R. Mhawish, a Palestinian journalist evacuated from Rafah, shares his harrowing escape and the turmoil of fleeing violence. Peter Beinart, Editor-at-Large at Jewish Currents, provides a historical framework for understanding the ongoing conflict. They discuss the emotional scars left by the October 7th attacks, delving into personal losses and the longing for home amid chaos. The conversation emphasizes the need for empathy and nuanced dialogue as they reflect on trauma, hope, and the complexities of identity in the face of war.
The chaotic aftermath of the October 7th attacks has forced individuals in Gaza, like Mohamed Mahawish, to constantly flee violence while grappling with the emotional toll of survival.
Despite the overwhelming despair, both Mahawish and Peter Beinart emphasize that hope remains essential, advocating for recognition, peace, and equality as pathways to a better future.
Deep dives
The Impact of October 7th
The events of October 7th have dramatically altered lives, particularly for those in Gaza. Mohamed Mahawish, a Gazan journalist, recounts waking up to explosions, feeling the immediate chaos erupting around him. He experienced the unprecedented breaches of the border, witnessing unprecedented reactions among his neighbors ranging from fear to awe. This day serves as a pivotal moment, marking a shift where individuals are left to grapple with the implications of such a monumental tragedy in their lives.
Experiences of Displacement and Survival
Survival in Gaza has become a constant struggle marked by displacement, as described by Mahawish, who fled multiple times to escape ongoing violence since the initial attack. He reflects on the fear of being targeted as a journalist and the frantic necessity to leave everything behind during bombardments. The reality of living under war has forced him and his family to continuously abandon shelters and seek safety, often without any clear destination. This chaotic existence emphasizes the precariousness of everyday life in a conflict zone, where safety is elusive.
The Complexity of Emotions in Crisis
Emotional turmoil has been a constant for both Mahawish and Peter Beinart, who experienced October 7th in a community where the news was met silently due to religious observances. Beinart describes the clash between the joyful celebrations of a holiday and the collective anxiety of a community perceiving dangerous whispers of violence. Both men express a profound struggle to find words to articulate their experiences and emotions in the aftermath of such an overwhelming tragedy. The interplay of fear, joy, and despair illustrates the complexity of navigating personal and communal reactions in times of crisis.
Hope Amidst Despair
Hope serves as an intrinsic part of identity for both Mahawish and Beinart, despite the despair surrounding them. Mahawish emphasizes that hope is not merely a choice but a fundamental aspect of being Palestinian, driving the desire for recognition and peace. He articulates a collective aspiration for a future free from mourning and violence, advocating for basic human rights. Beinart reflects on a broader movement, suggesting that amidst the turmoil, a growing awareness and call for equality among Palestinians and Jews may lead to more sustainable solutions in the future.
A year after the initial Hamas attack on Israel, tens of thousands are dead, bombs are still falling, a regional war is expanding, and there’s no end in sight. Two writers reflect on the destruction, loss, and death.
Mohammed R. Mhawish is Palestinian journalist who was evacuated from Rafah to Egypt in May.
Want more What Next? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme and Rob Gunther.