Philosophy Talk Starters 563: Derek Parfit and Your Future Self
May 4, 2025
Dive into the intriguing ideas of Derek Parfit, who challenges how we perceive our connection to future selves. Can psychological continuity redefine our understanding of identity? Explore the ethical implications of valuing ourselves versus others, alongside fascinating insights from science fiction writers on the subject. Engage with thought-provoking questions about personal survival and moral responsibilities, all while unraveling the mysteries of rational decision-making. It's a philosophical journey that could change how you view your future!
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Psychological Continuity Trumps Identity
- Derek Parfit argues identity isn't what matters; psychological continuity (memories, plans, character) matters more than strict numerical identity.
- Caring about past and future selves rests on psychological connections, not on being the exact same entity over time.
Transporter Creates Two 'Yous'
- Ray and Josh use the transporter thought experiment where a copy is made on Mars while the original remains on Earth.
- They ask which of the two is the real person and explore how both would claim to be the original.
Which Duplicate 'Matters' Depends On Relations
- Parfit suggests that even if two duplicates both remember and look the same, asking which is the 'real' you may miss the point.
- What matters ethically and prudentially are the strength of psychological ties, not a metaphysical label of personal identity.
