Is economists' favorite tool to crush inflation broken?
Sep 8, 2023
auto_awesome
Explore the story of economist Bill Phillips and the creation of the Phillips curve. Discover how it went mainstream and its impact on macroeconomics. Delve into its limitations in predicting inflation and the challenge of establishing universal laws in economics.
The Phillips curve, initially developed by Bill Phillips, showcased a trade-off between unemployment and inflation but has been challenged and found to be limited in accurately predicting real-world dynamics.
The failure of the Phillips curve to predict and control inflation highlights the ongoing complexity of the economy and the ongoing quest for a comprehensive understanding of its dynamics.
Deep dives
The Birth of the Phillips Curve
Bill Phillips, an engineer turned economist, built a water flow model to understand the economy's behavior. This model showcased the trade-off between unemployment and inflation, which eventually became known as the Phillips curve. The curve gained popularity and was seen as a tool to guide economic stability. However, Milton Friedman challenged the curve's accuracy and pointed out its limitations, especially in accounting for inflation expectations. This led to a reevaluation of the Phillips curve and the development of a more complex version, Phillips Curve 2.0.
The Deception of a Stable Relationship
During the 1960s and '70s, economists heavily relied on the Phillips curve, believing it was a stable relationship between unemployment and inflation. However, the stagflation of the 1970s showed that this belief was misguided. Influenced by supply shocks and inflation expectations, the Phillips curve failed to accurately predict the real-world dynamics of the economy. Economists, such as Alan Blinder, had to reassess their faith in the Phillips curve and its ability to guide effective monetary policy.
The Challenge of Unraveling Inflation
After achieving the soft landing of the economy, Alan Blinder found that inflation remained stable for decades despite various economic changes. The Phillips curve, even its updated version, didn't adequately explain this phenomenon. Losing confidence in the curve, economists faced challenges in understanding inflation drivers and navigating monetary policy effectively. The Phillips curve's failure to predict and control inflation highlights the complexity of the economy and the ongoing quest for a comprehensive understanding of its dynamics.
When economists and policymakers talk about getting inflation under control, there's an assumption they often make: bringing inflation down will probably result in some degree of layoffs and job loss. But that is not the way things have played out since inflation spiked last year. Instead, so far, inflation has come down, and unemployment has stayed low.
So where does the idea of this tradeoff – between inflation and unemployment – come from?
That story starts in the 1940s, with a soft-spoken electrical engineer-turned-crocodile hunter-turned-economist named Bill Phillips. Phillips was consumed by the notion that there are underlying forces at work in the economy. He thought that if macroeconomists could only understand how those forces work, they could keep the economy stable.
On today's show, how the Phillips Curve was born, why it went mainstream, and why universal truths remain elusive in macroeconomics.
This episode was hosted by Willa Rubin and Nick Fountain, and produced by Sam Yellowhorse Kesler. It was edited by Molly Messick, and engineered by Maggie Luthar. Sierra Juarez checked the facts.