Intelligence Squared

Max Hastings on On the Secret Mission to Defeat Hitler, Part Two

May 30, 2024
Max Hastings, a military historian and author of "Operation Biting," returns to discuss the pivotal British raid on Nazi Germany during World War II. He emphasizes the vital role of intelligence in warfare and the lessons learned from historical operations like Operation Biting. The conversation highlights the impact of political interference in military strategies and explores the human cost of war, including the suffering of civilians. Hastings also delves into the eccentric heroes of the French Resistance, showcasing their unexpected contributions to the fight against the Nazis.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Political Interference in Military

  • Constant communication enables political leaders to interfere with military decisions.
  • Hastings argues against this, citing potential for micromanagement and lack of ground-level understanding.
ANECDOTE

Falklands Backseat Driving

  • Max Hastings recounts excessive backseat driving during the Falklands War.
  • Northwood pressured Julian Thompson to attack Goose Green despite logistical and weather challenges.
ADVICE

Trust Generals, Not Politicians

  • Entrust military decisions to generals, not politicians.
  • While some political leaders possess military genius, many are unqualified, making generals a safer bet.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app