Unpacking Israeli History

Can Israel Have All the Land and Still Have Peace?

Oct 8, 2026
Rabbi Yehuda HaKohen, a West Bank educator and Religious Zionist thinker, offers a candid look inside the settler movement. He discusses why West Bank Jews feel misunderstood, the movement’s surprising diversity, Palestinian identity, and competing visions of one shared political reality. The conversation also explores Gaza, settler violence, Jewish identity, and the difficult path toward reconciliation.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Why Yehuda Rejects The Settler Label

  • Yehuda HaKohen argues that outsiders caricature West Bank Jews, Palestinians, and diaspora leftists instead of understanding each group’s self-perception.
  • He rejects “settler” because it implies Jews live somewhere they do not belong, while acknowledging some communities follow settler-colonial structures.
INSIGHT

The Two Contradictory Settler Spectrums

  • Yehuda HaKohen distinguishes affluent, state-protected communities from unfenced hilltop communities that see themselves as self-defending tribes.
  • He argues the most violent Jews may be better reconciliation candidates because warring tribes can become allies more readily than colonizer and colonized.
INSIGHT

Why Both Peoples Deny The Other’s Identity

  • Yehuda HaKohen rejects denying Palestinian identity while explaining why many Jews see it as fabricated propaganda.
  • He says Jews define peoplehood through ancestry, whereas Palestinians often define identity through the land’s successive indigenous populations.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app