The Herd with Colin Cowherd Colin Cowherd Podcast - Caleb IS The Bears Problem, Broncos BLOW OUT Cowboys, Trade AJ Brown? Drake Maye Is A STAR
Oct 27, 2025
Join John Middlekauff, a former NFL scout and host of the '3 and Out' podcast, as he dissects the latest NFL action. They delve into the Bears' woes, with Caleb Williams at the center of the discussion. The duo praises CJ Stroud's calm performance against a struggling 49ers team and debates the future of AJ Brown in Philadelphia. Also highlighted is Drake Maye's rise as a top quarterback and the Broncos' explosive win over the Cowboys, all while questioning the weak upcoming draft class for college quarterbacks.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Scripted Success, Late-Game Failure
- Caleb Williams excels on scripted, early-series plays but collapses when games go off-script in later quarters.
- Colin and John conclude Caleb's inconsistent accuracy and timing limit the Bears' offense despite talent.
Timing And Touch Are Nonnegotiable
- John Middlekauff argues Caleb lacks consistent accuracy and timing that fit Ben Johnson's system.
- He warns Caleb likely won't thrive in Johnson's offense without reliable touch on short throws.
Read The Coach's Body Language
- Watch Ben Johnson's body language to judge coach-player fit and future patience.
- If a coach seems resigned instead of demanding improvement, consider the quarterback-coach pairing at risk.