Tyler McCreary, author of Crisis in the Tar Sands, joins Lukas Slothuus and Ashok Kumar to discuss the future of tar sands in Canada, the rentier's dilemma, indigenous politics, the impact of automation, the war in Ukraine's effects on global energy markets, the interaction between decarbonization and automation, organizing the unemployed, and the perception of Canada's liberal capitalist development.
Understanding the contradictions and tensions within the tar sands industry is essential for a comprehensive analysis.
By broadening the conversation to include the political economy and class dynamics of production, a more inclusive and transformative climate politics can be developed.
Deep dives
The Conjunctural Analysis of Production in the Canadian Tar Sands
This podcast episode delves into an article by Tyler McCreary that analyzes the production in the Canadian tar sands. The article highlights five key tensions or conjunctures that shape tar sands development, including pipelines and infrastructure, indigenous rights, the Rantir's dilemma, decarbonization and transitions in the fossil economy, and automation. The episode discusses how conversations around the tar sands have been dominated by left moralism, neglecting the critical engagement with political economy. It argues that understanding the contradictions and tensions within the tar sands industry is essential for a comprehensive analysis.
The Rentier's Dilemma in the Tar Sands
The podcast explores the concept of the Rentier's dilemma within the context of the Canadian tar sands. It explains that states rely on cycles of investment to mobilize resources and face a dilemma between raising rents to gain better revenue but becoming less competitive, or lowering rents to attract investment but reducing revenue. The Rentier's dilemma is crucial in understanding the dynamics of tar sands development and is often overlooked in environmental discussions. By focusing on production rather than consumption, a more comprehensive understanding of the landscape of the tar sands can be achieved.
Moving Beyond Consumption to Production in Climate Politics
The episode discusses the importance of shifting the focus from consumption to production in climate politics. It criticizes certain environmental movements for predominantly targeting consumption and lifestyle choices without engaging with the underlying production processes. The speaker argues that understanding the tensions and contradictions in the production of fossil fuels is essential for effective climate action. By broadening the conversation to include the political economy and class dynamics of production, a more inclusive and transformative climate politics can be developed.
The Power Dynamics in the Tar Sands Economy
The podcast analyzes the power dynamics within the tar sands economy. It argues that power primarily resides in relations of global capital rather than state policy. While the provincial government of Alberta and domestic Canadian corporations hold some power, the broader influence lies within the dynamics of capital. The episode emphasizes the need for collective organizing and a class politics that goes beyond liberal environmentalism to address the injustices and contradictions embedded in the tar sands industry.