Mary Radcliffe, a senior researcher at FiveThirtyEight, and Elliot Morris, the editorial director of data, engage in a compelling discussion about democracy's importance to voters. They analyze a provocative comment from Trump's former chief of staff labeling Trump a "fascist" and its potential electoral implications. The pair dives into the voting behaviors of young men, highlighting their growing political disillusionment and shift towards independence. They also explore how anti-democratic actions, especially post-January 6th, impact voter perceptions.
36:38
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The podcast highlights concerns regarding Trump's alignment with fascist tendencies, revealing a complex voter sentiment towards democracy and anti-democratic behavior.
Polling data shows young men display significant disillusionment with political parties, complicating candidates' strategies to effectively engage this demographic.
Deep dives
Trump's Rally and Democratic Norms
Donald Trump's recent rally showcased familiar themes of crassness and norm-breaking behavior, prompting discussions about his alignment with fascist tendencies. Retired General John Kelly, who served as Trump's chief of staff, characterized Trump as fitting the general definition of a fascist, a sentiment echoed by Kamala Harris during a CNN town hall. This raises the question of how much the American voter is concerned about Trump's deviations from democratic norms, with the podcast host referencing a study indicating only a minimal percentage of voters might switch their allegiance based solely on such anti-democratic behavior. The complexity of public sentiment reveals that while symbolic support for democracy exists, practical electoral consequences remain limited.
Insights on Polling Data
Current polling data indicates an overall tied race between the candidates, with slight leads fluctuating in battleground states. The analysis of recent polls highlights discrepancies between likely voters and registered voters, emphasizing how voter behavior could differ in competitive versus non-competitive states. Although some media outlets have reported distinct leads for either candidate, the consensus remains that no conclusive trend has emerged, justifying a cautious approach to interpreting early voting data. The podcast emphasizes the need for patience as final voting outcomes and influences become clearer closer to election day.
Analyzing Young Men's Political Engagement
A targeted survey revealed that young men exhibit a distinctly more negative outlook on America compared to older counterparts, complicating the messaging strategies of political candidates. This demographic is reportedly disillusioned with both major parties, feeling that their needs are not adequately represented, which presents a challenge for candidates trying to engage them. Interestingly, Barack Obama remains a highly regarded figure among young men, suggesting that nostalgia for his leadership could play a role in their political preferences. The podcast suggests that these patterns in attitudes toward party dynamics may lead to lower overall turnout among young male voters this election cycle.
Implications of Public Sentiment and Messaging
The changing political narrative around Trump's behavior signals a strategic pivot for Kamala Harris as she aims to galvanize support by framing him as a threat to democracy in her closing campaign messages. This messaging aims to resonate with moderate voters while also potentially energizing the base, which feels concerned about Trump's conduct. While polls indicate that Harris performs better than Trump on issues around democracy, the effectiveness of this strategy remains uncertain as messages targeting distinct voter segments might conflict. Overall, the layering of such narratives underscores the need for careful navigation of voter sentiment leading up to the election.
Last week, John Kelly, former President Donald Trump’s longest-serving chief of staff, said Trump fit the definition of a “fascist.” Democrats have seized on the comment, using it to underline Trump’s anti-democratic tendencies in these final days before Election Day.
On this installment of the 538 Politics podcast, the crew discusses how much voters care about democracy. And they look at a new poll that might shed light on the behavior of a new group of swing voters: young men.
