Firearms expert Darryl Bolke, gun enthusiast Caleb Giddings, tactical instructor Bryan Eastridge, law enforcement officer Chuck Haggard, and firearms instructor Steve Shields discuss the history and design of the 357 Magnum revolver, the reliability of revolvers as backup weapons, the rise and fall of the Model 20 and 21 handguns, gun options for the 357 Magnum round, the power and limitations of the 357 Magnum round, exploring firearms and ammunition performance, bullet types and loads, developing a penetrating load for windshield glass and critical organs, ethical shooting and effective penetration, the musket ball pistol bullet analogy, effective calibers for self-defense, shooting 200 rounds of 357, preserving knowledge and passion for revolvers, and the versatility of revolvers.
The 357 Magnum offers versatility for both hunting and self-defense, with different bullet weights and velocities tailored to specific needs.
Larger frames like the Model 27, Model 28, and Model 586 are better suited to handle full power 357 Magnum loads, improving durability and reliability.
Finding the right balance between power and recoil is crucial when shooting 357 Magnum, with options like 38 special loads or lower power 357 Magnum loads helping to mitigate recoil while maintaining stopping power.
Addressing concerns about overpenetration with 357 Magnum loads can be achieved through the selection of appropriate ammunition, such as hollow points.
Revolvers offer versatility, reliability, and accuracy for various purposes, with the option to shoot different types of ammunition and function in different shooting positions.
Deep dives
The Evolution of 357 Magnum
The podcast discusses the history and evolution of the 357 Magnum. Originally designed as a high-powered round for hunting and car puncturing, the reputation of the round was made in the 70s and 80s as a result of its use in law enforcement during that time. However, the performance of the round has changed over time, and it is now understood that it is better suited for specific applications. Different bullet weights and velocities can be tailored to different needs, making it a versatile option for both hunting and self-defense.
Choosing the Right Gun for 357 Magnum
The discussion explores the benefits of using end frames, such as the Model 27, Model 28, and Model 586, for shooting 357 Magnum loads. These larger and more robust frames are better suited to handle the pressures and recoil associated with shooting full power 357 Magnum loads, making them more durable and reliable. Other frames, such as K frames, may struggle with the pressures and can experience timing issues or excessive wear. The GP 100 is also mentioned as a solid choice for shooting 357 Magnum.
Balancing Power and Recoil
The importance of finding the right balance between power and recoil when shooting 357 Magnum is emphasized. While the round can offer significant stopping power, it can also generate a significant amount of recoil, making it challenging to shoot accurately. Choosing the right ammunition, such as 38 special loads or lower power 357 Magnum loads, can help mitigate recoil and make shooting more manageable while still maintaining adequate stopping power.
The Controversy of Overpenetration
The episode touches on the debates surrounding overpenetration with 357 Magnum loads. While the round can provide excellent penetration for hunting or defensive purposes, there is always a concern about the potential for collateral damage or excessive penetration. Selecting the appropriate ammunition, such as hollow points, can help address these concerns and reduce the risk of overpenetration.
The Versatility of Revolvers
Revolvers offer a unique level of versatility and reliability. They can be used for various purposes such as self-defense, target shooting, small game hunting, and even as car guns. Revolvers are known for their accuracy and their ability to function in different shooting positions. They also provide the option to shoot different types of ammunition, including snake shot, wad cutters, and defensive loads. With proper training and practice, revolvers can be an effective and reliable choice for personal protection.
Bullet Performance and Considerations
When selecting ammunition for defensive purposes, factors like penetration and shot placement become crucial. The concept of bullet performance should go beyond simply focusing on expansion. Penetration, especially to reach vital organs, is crucial for stopping an assailant effectively. The design envelope of a bullet is also important, as different bullet configurations cater to specific needs, such as penetrating bone, expanding in soft tissue, or providing deep penetration. Balancing velocity and bullet design is crucial to achieving desired terminal performance.
Understanding the Sweet Spot for Ammunition
There is a sweet spot when it comes to ammunition performance, where bullet weight, velocity, and penetration are balanced effectively. This sweet spot varies depending on the purpose of the ammunition, whether it be for self-defense, hunting, or target shooting. It is important not to fall for marketing hype and focus on proper testing and understanding of ammunition performance. Super light and super fast loads may not always provide the desired results. Research and testing should be conducted to find the ammunition that falls within the effective sweet spot for each specific application.
The Importance of Proper Bullet Penetration and Bullet Selection
The podcast episode emphasizes the significance of bullet penetration and selecting the right bullets for various firearms. The speaker asserts that deeper penetration and proper bullet construction are crucial for neutralizing threats effectively, regardless of caliber or velocity. They discuss the importance of bullets that can penetrate deeply enough to reach vital organs and incapacitate the target rather than relying solely on velocity or magic bullet concepts. The speaker also mentions the use of water cutters for improved penetration, emphasizing the need to match bullet velocity, shape, and weight to the intended purpose and firearm.
The Versatility and Training Benefits of Revolvers
The podcast episode highlights the benefits of owning and training with revolvers, especially in a modern context. The discussion emphasizes revolvers as useful tools for training, particularly for individuals struggling with trigger control, flinching, or grip issues. The speakers recommend owning a double-action revolver in .22 caliber and a .357 Magnum revolver for marksmanship training, as these platforms offer unique advantages that can address these common shooting challenges. They stress the importance of preserving revolver knowledge and promoting the continued use of revolvers, not only for defensive purposes but also for hunting, target shooting, and overall enjoyment.
