AUDIO: Bob Jones on plans for a PCB dump in Lee, Massachusetts
Jul 31, 2023
auto_awesome
Bob Jones discusses the incomplete PCB cleanup of the Housatonic River, revealing only 30% removal. Controversy surrounds plans for a toxic waste dump in Lee, Massachusetts, with lack of transparency and environmental risks. The podcast dives into legal and ethical concerns, public outrage, and the potential consequences of leaving PCBs in the river. Reflections on the federal court case and community engagement highlight the ongoing environmental challenges.
The Rest of River Cleanup Agreement will not remove all PCBs from the Housatonic River, impacting human health and wildlife.
The PCB dump site in Lee raises environmental and health concerns due to its proximity to a freshwater aquifer.
The lack of community involvement and transparency in the PCB cleanup decision-making process has led to misconceptions.
Deep dives
The Inadequacy of the Rest of River Cleanup Plan
The Rest of River Cleanup Agreement, approved in 2020 by the Lee Select Board and other towns, will not remove all PCBs from the Housatonic River. Despite residents' assumptions, the cleanup will not fully restore the river to a safe, healthy state. The plan includes disposing of some PCB-laden river sediment at a new 20-acre dump site in Lee, located near a freshwater aquifer and only 15 feet above the water table. This approach differs from the original EPA's 2016 permit, which aimed to send all PCB waste to out-of-state disposal facilities.
Economic Impact of the Cleanup Agreement
GE's challenge of the EPA-approved plan resulted in a 2020 settlement agreement costing around $550 million, $60 million less than the 2016 plan. The agreement includes payments to Pittsfield and five towns for removal of more river sediment than initially proposed. However, Lee is concerned about potential property value decrease due to the PCB dump and the financial implications of handling the cleanup, which may lead to lawsuits from residents.
Concerns About PCB Contamination and Cleanup Effectiveness
Residents, led by Bob Jones, dispute the Rest of River Cleanup Plan's effectiveness, suggesting that only about 30% of PCB contamination will be removed, impacting both human health and wildlife. The collective agree that the dump site in Lee is flawed and poses environmental injustice by burdening a working-class community. Residents express concerns over PCB dispersal during intense storms and the dump's proximity to a freshwater aquifer.
Lack of Transparency and Community Engagement in Cleanup Process
Concerns are raised about the lack of community involvement and transparency in the decision-making process regarding the PCB cleanup. The negotiation process, involving closed-door meetings and limited public disclosure, led to misconceptions about the cleanup plan. Residents critique the secretive nature of the agreements made between select boards, highlighting the need for more open dialogue and accurate dissemination of information to residents.
Environmental Impact and Legal Challenges
The disposal of PCB-laden river sediment in Lee raises environmental and health concerns for the surrounding communities. Litigation in progress, and future lawsuits planned, address the inadequate cleanup plan and the adverse impact on property values and public health. Efforts are underway to challenge the plan's implementation and push for more comprehensive and transparent solutions that prioritize environmental protection and community well-being.
When news headlines refer to “the Housatonic River clean-up,” some assume that the GE-funded and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)-approved remediation work will remove all PCB contamination and return the river to a safe, healthy state.
But as Bob Jones, chair of the Select Board in the Town of Lee, Massachusetts, explains in this podcast conversation, that’s not the case. The “Rest of River” cleanup agreement approved in 2020 by the Select Boards of Lee, Lenox, Stockbridge, Great Barrington and Sheffield will not remove all of the PCBs. Jones argues that perhaps as little as 30 percent of the contamination that makes the river and surrounding area unhealthy for people and wildlife will be removed.
As a result, he told me, “You and I will never eat fish out of the Housatonic River.”
The Berkshire Argus: Important stories fully told.