Tim Alberta, a seasoned journalist and author at The Atlantic, dives into how politics have pervaded the white evangelical church, especially post-Trump. He delves into the emotional toll of deportations on communities and examines the evolving perspectives within evangelicalism. Alberta shares insights on the shifting alliances around issues like abortion and the political landscape among Hispanic voters. Ultimately, he and Moore discuss the importance of fostering hope and building community amidst societal divisions.
Tim Alberta emphasizes the pervasive political polarization within evangelical communities, exacerbated by recent elections and the numbing effect on congregants' beliefs.
The podcast discusses a growing resignation among voters, revealing disillusionment with both political parties and a perceived lack of meaningful persuasion.
Deep dives
Valentine's Day Promotions and Comfort Apparel
The episode highlights Valentine's Day promotions offered by MeUndies, providing listeners with an opportunity to purchase comfortable undies and loungewear. The variety of Valentine's Day prints allows customers to match with loved ones or pets, making it a fun gifting option. The special savings available on their website encourage listeners to consider these products for their Valentine gifts. Overall, the message emphasizes both comfort and creativity in personal gift choices.
Political Polarization in Evangelical Communities
The podcast discusses the persistent political polarization within evangelical communities, particularly in light of the recent presidential election. Tim Alberta shares insights from his book 'The Kingdom, the Power, and the Glory,' highlighting tensions arising in churches amid political debates. Many congregations have seen divisions that were previously considered healed, suggesting a numbing effect among congregants regarding their political beliefs. The self-selection of church members, who either sought out churches with politics aligning or distancing from them, contributes to the ongoing challenges within these communities.
Resignation Among Voters and Political Disillusionment
Listeners are informed of a growing sentiment of resignation among voters, impacting both Trump's supporters and detractors. The podcast suggests that many voters believe that despite their personal opinions regarding Trump, enduring his presidency isn't viewed as catastrophic. This resignation highlights a belief that the political landscape has become so polarized that meaningful persuasion no longer exists. The erosion of moral clarity among voters reflects a broader disillusionment with both major political parties, complicating future elections.
Changing Dynamics of the Republican Party and Evangelicals
The episode details the shifting relationship between the Republican Party and evangelical leaders, particularly regarding Trump's reelection campaign. Many traditional evangelical influencers have been sidelined, reflecting a strategic shift in Trump's approach. This change may indicate a diminishing role for evangelicals in shaping the party's policies moving forward, despite their historical significance. Additionally, the rise of Pentecostal influences within Trump's support base raises questions about the future of evangelical engagement in politics, particularly concerning social and cultural issues.
In December of 2023, journalist and author Tim Alberta joined Russell Moore to discuss the ways that politics have invaded the white evangelical church in recent years. He returns to talk about the election and inauguration of President Donald Trump that have happened since—and to consider what those events mean about the state of American culture.
Alberta and Moore talk about numbness, hopelessness, and the lack of persuadability in many Americans. They discuss the effect of social media on righteous indignation and judgmentalism as well as the political exhaustion among wide swaths of Americans. They talk about President Trump’s executive orders, cabinet members, and the possibility of mass deportations.
Moore and Alberta describe their reasons for hope and consider what it may look like to build godly community in a time of division.
Resources mentioned in this episode or recommended by the guest include: