Novara FM: Our New Cyberboss Overlords w/ Craig Gent
Sep 27, 2024
auto_awesome
Craig Gent, North of England editor for Novara Media and author of a book on algorithmic management, dives into the realm of algorithmic oversight in the workplace. He discusses how tech giants like Amazon and gig economy platforms exploit workers through constant surveillance. Gent highlights the innovative resistance workers are forming, such as Deliveroo riders using WhatsApp to strike. He also critiques the adaptability of trade unions and the growing disconnect with today's labor needs amidst evolving technological challenges.
The shift to algorithmic management, particularly in gig economy firms, has resulted in intensified worker monitoring and exploitation despite illusions of autonomy.
Workers subjected to algorithmic oversight have developed informal forms of resistance, such as slowdowns and secret codes to regain agency against productivity pressures.
The paradox of transparency in algorithmic workplaces undermines collective action, as both workers and managers struggle to understand the systems controlling labor.
Deep dives
The Rise of Algorithmic Management
The emergence of algorithmic management has become a dominant feature of many workplaces, impacting how companies structure labor and control employees. Algorithms track worker performance through various devices, effectively replacing traditional management with digital oversight. This shift has been particularly evident in gig economy companies like Uber and Amazon, where workers face severe monitoring and stringent quotas. As a result, the transparency of workplace operations has diminished, leading to a lack of understanding about how these systems function among both employees and employers.
The Illusion of Worker Autonomy
The gig economy often promotes the notion of worker freedom and choice, yet this autonomy is largely superficial. While workers can select their hours, they are continuously monitored and pressured to meet performance targets dictated by algorithms. This creates a scenario where, despite the appearance of flexibility, workers are still subjected to high-stress environments and exploitation. The tension between the promise of autonomy and the reality of control is a central paradox in discussions about modern labor dynamics.
Resistance in the Age of Algorithms
Workers facing algorithmic management have developed various forms of resistance, though these tactics tend to be informal and individualistic. For instance, incidences of 'slowdowns' by agency workers demonstrate attempts to reclaim agency against algorithms dictating their productivity. Additionally, secret codes have been shared to allow workers to bypass productivity monitoring for unsanctioned breaks. While these acts of resistance may seem minor, they highlight a growing awareness among workers of their rights within a heavily monitored framework.
The Transparency Trap
The concept of transparency in algorithmic workplaces presents a paradox, as the systems intended to ensure efficiency often obfuscate the realities of work. Managers may rely on algorithms to inform decision-making, yet many remain as uninformed about employee engagement as the workers themselves. This opacity can foster dissatisfaction and confusion, hindering any potential for collective action. Workers feeling disconnected from each other, due to the digitalized nature of their responsibilities, face greater challenges when trying to organize effectively.
Future Implications of AI in Workplaces
As AI technology rapidly advances, the implications for labor and workplace organization appear increasingly complex. The recent rise in labor-centric AI applications has led to heightened discussions surrounding their potential for both efficiency and exploitation. While the Writers Guild of America showcased a bold stance against AI encroachment in creative sectors, many unions still grapple with the challenge of fully comprehending and negotiating the intricacies of algorithmic systems. Ultimately, addressing these evolving technologies requires a reevaluation of worker rights and the dynamics of labor relations in a digital age.
How can we resist exploitation when the boss has been replaced by a computer? That’s the premise of Cyberboss, a new book by Craig Gent, North of England editor for Novara Media, which explains how “algorithmic management” is being rolled out in the workplace, starting with Amazon packers, Deliveroo drivers and online supermarket shoppers. He […]
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode