Tokens: The Future of Money in the Age of the Platform (gang gang mmm ice cream so good)
Feb 4, 2024
auto_awesome
Rachel O'Dwyer, writer and lecturer in Digital Cultures, discusses the history and function of tokens, the relationship between money and tokens, and the role of tokens in social control. They also touch on the affordances of tokens and provide advice for token design.
Tokens have specific restrictions that make them less fungible than traditional money but also have social and communicative functions.
Tokens have a long history and exist in gray and black markets, allowing platforms to operate without legal responsibilities.
Tokens serve as a regulatory loophole for platforms to perform bank-like activities without obtaining financial licenses, enabling control and flexibility in their operations.
Deep dives
Tokens as exchange media with strings attached
Tokens, such as Amazon gift card balances, often come with specific restrictions on how they can be used and by whom. For example, Amazon pays Mechanical Turk workers in gift card balances that can only be redeemed on the Amazon store and only by the worker. These tokens have strings attached that constrain their use, making them less fungible than traditional money. However, tokens also have social and communicative functions, being used to brag, troll, and communicate. For instance, Dogecoin was historically used to hat people on the internet for money content. Tokens are more than money in that they are easier to socialize and can encode various values beyond exchange value.
Tokens in historical context
Tokens have a long history and have always existed alongside traditional economies. There have been tokens for relief, earmarked for the poor, and tokens for identification purposes, such as orphan tokens in Victorian times. Tokens can also be found in gray and black markets, where they operate both for platform owners and users. For example, Twitch uses bits as tokens to tip streamers, technically stating that they have no monetary value, but they can be cashed out as money. This gray area allows platforms to employ individuals and act as payment processors without the legal responsibilities associated with them. Tokens have also been used in adult entertainment sites as a workaround for payment issues associated with traditional payment processors.
Tokens as a regulatory workaround
Tokens can act as a regulatory loophole for platforms, allowing them to perform bank-like activities without obtaining financial licenses. By categorizing tokens as something other than money, platforms can employ individuals, facilitate payments, and engage in financial activities without officially being employers or payments processors. Platforms use tokens to create this gray area of employment and payment, providing a space where they can operate without taking on the risks or responsibilities associated with traditional employment and financial institutions. Tokens serve as a mechanism for platforms to exert control and maintain flexibility in their operations.
The Historical Context of Crypto: Seeking to Decentralize Power
The podcast episode explores the historical context of the crypto movement, particularly its relation to attempts to decentralize power. It highlights that the surge of interest in crypto during the 2008 financial crisis was not entirely new, as similar ideas had already existed within niche groups like anarchist and libertarian communities. The episode delves into the blend of socialism and free market principles within American anarchism, particularly in Silicon Valley. It also discusses the various attempts to redesign money and create alternative systems that challenged traditional financial intermediaries. Ultimately, the episode raises questions about the blurry line between legitimate financial activities and scams, as well as the limitations and challenges of decentralizing power in practice.
Tokens, Values, and Affordances: Rethinking the Role of Crypto in Society
The podcast episode explores the possibilities and limitations of tokens, particularly in the context of crypto. It emphasizes the need for a better understanding of capital and money in today's capitalist system, questioning the assumption that decentralization automatically leads to more freedom. The episode discusses the potential of tokens to imbue values beyond financial transactions, such as care for others or the environment. It also raises the idea of non-fungibility as a means to invite different behaviors and affordances rather than enforcing them. Ultimately, the episode suggests the importance of considering how tokens and crypto can facilitate alternative forms of interaction and cooperation in society, while also acknowledging the challenges and complexities associated with these technologies.
Tokens have increasingly more popular beyond just in the crypto world *gang gang mmm ice cream so good*. Tokens are not new, but how they have been used and their proliferation have exploded with the rise of digital platforms.
During the interview we spoke about the history of tokens well before the internet, how tokens are both more and less than money, and the way tokens have been used for social control. We also talk about the affordances of tokens and some advice for those designing tokens.
If you liked the podcast be sure to give it a review on your preferred podcast platform. If you find content like this important consider donating to my Patreon starting at just $3 per month. It takes quite a lot of my time and resources so any amount helps. Follow me on Twitter (@TBSocialist) or Mastodon (@theblockchainsocialist@social.coop) and join the r/CryptoLeftists subreddit and Discord to join the discussion.
ICYMI I've written a book about, no surprise, blockchains through a left political framework! The title is Blockchain Radicals: How Capitalism Ruined Crypto and How to Fix Itand is being published through Repeater Books, the publishing house started by Mark Fisher who’s work influenced me a lot in my thinking.
The book is officially published and you use this linktree to find where you can purchase the book based on your region / country.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
