Best of 2024: As a teenager, John was jailed for assaulting someone and stealing their bike. That was 17 years ago – will he ever be released?
Dec 23, 2024
auto_awesome
In this conversation, journalist Sophie Atkinson, an author for The Guardian, dives into John Wright's harrowing journey. She reveals the controversial Indeterminate Public Protection (IPP) sentences in the UK and their devastating effects on mental health. John's struggles with identity and rehabilitation highlight the complexities faced by youthful offenders. As he battles schizophrenia during his prolonged incarceration, the emotional toll on him and his family becomes evident, illuminating the dire need for systemic reform in the justice system.
The introduction of Indeterminate Public Protection sentences led to unforeseen consequences, resulting in thousands of inmates facing prolonged incarceration for minor offenses.
John's traumatic journey reflects the devastating mental health impact of indefinite sentences, deteriorating not only his well-being but also his family's emotional stability.
Deep dives
The Impact of IPP Sentences
IPP sentences, or Imprisonment for Public Protection, have resulted in thousands of individuals being incarcerated indefinitely for crimes that previously would have merited shorter sentences. Introduced in the UK in 2003, this legislation aimed to protect the public from serious offenders but ultimately expanded to include many minor offenses, leading to a dramatic rise in the number of prisoners affected. Initially expected to encompass a few hundred individuals, over 6,000 prisoners were serving IPP sentences by the time the sentence was abolished in 2012. The enforcement of these sentences has led to a significant amount of discussion regarding their fairness and the ethical implications of punishing individuals for potential future crimes.
John's Teenage Life and Early Criminality
John's life as a teenager was reflective of a typical youth, filled with creativity and familial affection, but it eventually spiraled into criminality that led to his incarceration. Initially a quiet and playful child, John fell in with a wrong crowd, culminating in a robbery incident that resulted in a significant prison sentence. Despite having a supportive family, including an older brother who had previously faced the justice system, John's poor choices led to a swift decline. Notably, John entered a young offender institution at 16, marking the beginning of a long and traumatic journey through the penal system.
The Burden of IPP Sentencing on Mental Health
The uncertainty surrounding IPP sentences has been correlated with severe mental health issues among inmates, as exemplified by John's deterioration over the years. After repeatedly being denied parole, John's mental state worsened, leading to bouts of paranoia, depression, and episodes of self-harm. Reports show that the incidence of self-harm and mental health crises among IPP prisoners is notably higher than among those serving life sentences. The absence of a definitive release date created an environment of hopelessness, exacerbated by punitive mental health treatments that often fail to address the underlying trauma experienced by prisoners like John.
Family Struggles and Systemic Failures
John's family faced insurmountable emotional struggles as they navigated his long-term incarceration under an IPP sentence. As the years passed, family visits dwindled due to prison relocations, leaving the family feeling disconnected and helpless as John's mental health deteriorated. John’s mother, in particular, experienced a profound sense of loss, feeling as though she had been robbed of her son’s adulthood, compounded by the passing of his father without being able to say goodbye. This tragic narrative highlights the failures of the system, where the desired rehabilitative intent was overshadowed by a punitive approach, leaving families fragmented and despairing for their loved ones’ futures.
Every Monday and Friday for the rest of December we will publish some of our favourite audio long reads of 2023, in case you missed them, with an introduction from the editorial team to explain why we’ve chosen it. From June: Indeterminate sentences are devastating to mental health, but prisoners with mental illness are less likely to be released. The result is a vicious cycle whereby the most vulnerable inmates often have the least chance of getting out – as John’s case shows. By Sophie Atkinson. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/longreadpod
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode