Marked by Grace How Can God Be Good When He Allows Evil to Happen?
One of humanity's most persistent theological questions is thoroughly examined in this episode of Marked by Grace. Pastor Heath Lambert tackles the challenging problem of evil and God's goodness, providing three classical Christian responses that have guided believers through centuries of doubt and difficulty.
Whether you're wrestling with personal suffering or trying to understand God's character in a broken world, this episode offers biblical clarity on why God can remain perfectly good while allowing evil to exist.
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 - Introduction: The Persistent Question of Evil and God's Goodness
1:08 - The Specific Question: Why Doesn't God Intervene Like We Should?
2:08 - Granting the Premise: When Human Inaction Becomes Sin
3:21 - God's Perfect Nature: Light with No Darkness
4:08 - Response 1: Primary vs Secondary Causes Explained
5:24 - Genesis 50:20 - Joseph's Brothers and God's Sovereignty
7:27 - The Shakespeare and Hamlet Analogy
8:34 - Response 2: All Evil as Judgment Against Human Sinfulness
10:27 - Luke 13:5 - Jesus on the Tower of Siloam
11:04 - Response 3: The Greater Good - God's Ultimate Plan
12:10 - Romans 8:28 - All Things Work Together for Good
13:19 - The Cross: Ultimate Example of Good from Evil
14:16 - Eternal Perspective: Praising God for His Redemptive Power
KEY POINTS
- The Question Explored: If humans are morally obligated to intervene when witnessing evil acts like assault or abuse, how can God witness atrocities daily without intervening and still be considered good and just?
- Primary vs Secondary Causes: God operates as the sovereign primary cause behind all events, while humans act as secondary causes. Evil is always chargeable to secondary causes (human sin) never to the primary cause (God). This distinction explains how the same event can have both a sinful human motivation and a righteous divine purpose.
- Universal Human Sinfulness: All people live in a fallen world where we deserve judgment, not blessing. The real theological question isn't "Why do bad things happen?" but rather "Why do any good things happen to sinners like us?" Every person deserves divine judgment due to their rebellion against God.
- The Greater Good Principle: God's omnipotent righteousness enables Him to bring ultimate good out of every evil situation. This doesn't make evil good, but demonstrates God's power to redeem and transform even the worst circumstances for His glory and our benefit.
- The Cross as Ultimate Example: Jesus Christ's crucifixion represents the worst act of victimization in human history, yet God transformed this ultimate evil into the means of salvation for countless people. This demonstrates how God can use even the most horrific events to accomplish his perfect purposes.
- Eternal Perspective: In eternity, believers will praise God not despite the suffering that occurred, but because of how He used that suffering to accomplish His glorious redemptive plan. The eternal weight of glory will far exceed any temporary affliction.
Submit your questions for future episodes to MarkedByGrace@fbcjax.com
SCRIPTURE REFERENCES
1 John 1:5 - "God is light and in him is no darkness at all" - Establishes God's perfect, sinless nature
Genesis 50:20 - "As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good, to bring it about that many people should be kept alive, as they are today" - Primary example of primary vs secondary causes
Luke 13:5 - Jesus' warning about the tower of Siloam - All people deserve judgment without repentance
Romans 8:28 - "We know that for those who love God all things work together for good, for those who are called according to his purpose" - The greater good principle
2 Corinthians 4:17 - "This light momentary affliction is preparing for us an eternal weight of glory beyond all comparison" - Eternal perspective on suffering