What If Christianity Never Existed? with Historian Tom Holland
Apr 21, 2023
auto_awesome
Historian Tom Holland joins the podcast to discuss the impact of Christianity on secularism, humanism, sexual morality, and the development of science. They also delve into Holland's upcoming book on the Roman Empire and explore the influence of Islam on the world. Book recommendations and the concept of progress influenced by Christianity are touched upon.
Christianity has had a profound influence on Western culture, shaping values and assumptions in various aspects of society.
Christianity played a significant role in shaping the development and progress of science.
Christianity played a crucial role in the abolition of slavery, despite the fact that there is no specific condemnation of slavery in the Bible.
Deep dives
Christianity's Impact on Western Culture
Christianity has had a profound influence on Western culture, shaping values and assumptions in various aspects of society. For example, Christianity played a role in overturning old patriarchal norms, allowing women more freedom and choice in marriage. It also introduced the concept of consent in marriage, emphasizing the importance of individual choice over coercion. Additionally, Christianity brought forth the idea of a two-dimensional worldview, separating the secular and the religious, which has profoundly shaped how Western societies understand and organize themselves. These distinct dimensions can be seen through the establishment of legal frameworks for marriages and the emergence of secularism as a concept. The influence of Christianity on Western values goes beyond morality and ethics, touching upon various aspects of society.
Christianity's Influence on the Development of Science
Christianity played a significant role in shaping the development and progress of science. The belief in an all-powerful God who created and governed the universe laid the foundation for exploring the laws and phenomenon of nature. Christian thinkers saw the study of the natural world as a means to understand God's creation, recognizing that reason and observation could unveil divine laws. The idea that God binds his power through covenantal agreements also allowed for the assumption that humans could comprehend and access these laws through reason. Therefore, the emergence of what is now known as science was rooted in a Christian context, as both the belief in an ordered universe and the idea of human reason being able to uncover its laws were essential in the development of scientific methodology.
The Rise of Christianity and Historical Explanation
The rise of Christianity poses an intriguing historical question, the belief in Christ's resurrection, which fueled the emergence and growth of the early Christian community. While the methodology of history does not delve into supernatural explanations, it acknowledges the impact of belief on historical events and analyzes the influence of these beliefs on individuals and societies. Historians can examine the reasons why the early Christians believed in the resurrection without making claims about the historical truth of the event itself. Similarly, the reception of the Quran in Islam presents a similar mystery, where the belief in its divine origin was deeply ingrained from the beginning, despite uncertainty regarding its historical origins. These matters fall within the domain of theology, faith, and individual interpretation rather than historical analysis.
The influence of Christianity on the abolition of slavery
Christianity played a crucial role in the abolition of slavery, despite the fact that there is no specific condemnation of slavery in the Bible. The early Christian church recognized slavery as part of a fallen world, akin to hunger and poverty. However, this perspective began to change in the fourth century with Bishop Gregory of Nisah, who argued that slavery was against God's will and should be abolished. This radical idea took time to gain traction within Christianity, but eventually, in the 18th and 19th centuries, Protestants and Catholics alike came to see abolition as a moral imperative. The fusion of Protestant and Catholic beliefs on the abolition of slavery laid the foundation for international law and paved the way for the British Royal Navy to impound slave ships of Catholic nations. Despite facing challenges in Muslim countries due to differing interpretations of Islam, the movement to abolish the slave trade drew inspiration from Christian values of equality and the intrinsic worth of all human beings.
Christianity's influence on moral values and the question of a secular society
Christianity has played a significant role in shaping moral values in Western societies, and the question of whether a secular society can adopt Christian values without religion lies in a complex realm. The values promoted by Christianity, such as recognizing the inherent worth of every individual, challenging established hierarchies, and prioritizing care for the poor and marginalized, have found resonance across secular societies. However, without a shared belief in God, the interpretations and adherence to these values may differ. For example, the tension between sexual liberation and the responsibility to protect the vulnerable reveals the challenges of maintaining Christian values without the underlying religious foundation. The continuing debate and ambivalence in secular societies underscore the ever-evolving nature of moral values and the need for ongoing reflection on the role of Christianity in shaping them.
I am joined by the historian Tom Holland to help me look at the possibility of Christianity had never existed. What would the world look like today if Jesus never launched the world's largest and most influential religion?Check Out Everything I Do Support the Show.WATCH Inspiring Philosophy on Youtube!https://www.youtube.com/@InspiringPhilosophy
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
