A clash of coding cultures unfolds as Rust is integrated into the Linux kernel. Developers are divided over its adoption, with concerns about security and maintainers' burnout taking center stage. Personal experiences reveal the emotional toll of community dynamics, while discussions highlight the need for collaboration between C and Rust. Community insights shine through meetups and anecdotes, emphasizing the bonds formed in tech. Plus, explore encrypted storage solutions and innovative HomeLab adventures.
The integration of Rust into the Linux kernel aims to enhance security and attract younger developers, despite challenges faced in adoption.
The emotional toll of kernel development is highlighted by burnout caused by non-technical disputes, which threaten community collaboration.
Maintaining interoperability between Rust and existing C code is a critical challenge, necessitating clear communication to ensure shared infrastructure remains consistent.
Deep dives
The Introduction of Rust in the Linux Kernel
The ongoing integration of Rust into the Linux kernel is centered on enhancing security, reliability, and maintainability. C remains the primary language for kernel development, but the inclusion of Rust aims to attract a different range of developers and tackle long-term sustainability concerns. Interestingly, there is a noticeable generational contrast among maintainers, with Rust potentially engaging younger developers, which may alleviate some pressures on the aging maintainer community. The conversation often highlights that while Rust is expected to revolutionize certain areas, a total transition away from C will not happen anytime soon.
Challenges Faced with Integration
Despite initial enthusiasm, the integration of Rust has faced significant challenges, especially regarding developer familiarity with the language. Linus Torvalds has expressed disappointment at the slower than expected progress, revealing a gap between seasoned C developers and those willing to learn Rust. Compounding this issue is the stability of the Rust infrastructure, which has not yet reached a level that encourages wide adoption among kernel developers. The combination of these hurdles has led to frustration within the community, with fears about potential stagnation in kernel development.
Maintainer Burnout and Community Dynamics
The resignation of a long-time Rust maintainer has brought attention to the emotional toll of kernel development amidst technical disagreements. Burnout is primarily attributed to non-technical discussions that challenge the collaborative spirit necessary for healthy open-source contribution. Conversations about Rust have become heated and divisive, showcasing the tensions between traditionalists favoring C and advocates for Rust. This delicate balance within the community has raised concerns about sustaining enthusiasm among maintainers, leading to questions about future collaboration on kernel projects.
Technical Concerns Regarding Rust and C Interoperability
A significant technical challenge of incorporating Rust into the Linux kernel involves ensuring interoperability with existing C code, which is crucial for maintaining shared infrastructure. As developers work to create Rust bindings and maintain them concurrently with C code changes, there is a growing concern regarding the potential for inconsistencies. Calls for clear communication about semantics and interface changes are vital for both the Rust and C communities, highlighting the need for established processes to avoid fragmentation. The conversation reveals a broader debate about maintaining high code quality while accommodating new languages within established ecosystems.
The Future of Rust in Kernel Development
Looking ahead, there are differing viewpoints within the community about the future impact of Rust on kernel development. While some argue for its potential benefits in building secure and robust components, others remain skeptical until clearer success indicators emerge. The integration seems destined to be a prolonged journey, akin to historical projects such as real-time Linux, which took decades to materialize fully. Despite this, there remains a cautious optimism that Rust could eventually play an integral role in kernel advancements.
Cultural Shifts and Perspectives
The cultural landscape of the Linux kernel development community is also undergoing shifts as new developers bring fresh perspectives, particularly around Rust. This evolution reflects a broader societal change in software development, where modern languages and practices challenge traditional norms. Conversations often reveal a mix of resistance and curiosity about adapting to new methodologies, with some developers embracing change, while others cling to established practices. This cultural dichotomy will be crucial in determining how seamlessly new technologies are embraced in the long term.
Rust for filesystems — At the 2024 Linux Storage, Filesystem, Memory Management, and BPF Summit, Wedson Almeida Filho and Kent Overstreet led a combined storage and filesystem session on using Rust for Linux filesystems.
One Of The Rust Linux Kernel Maintainers Steps Down - Cites "Nontechnical Nonsense" — One of the several Rust for Linux kernel maintainers has decided to step away from the project. The move is being driven at least in part due to having to deal with increased "nontechnical nonsense" raised around Rust programming language use within the Linux kernel.
On Rust, Linux, developers, maintainers — There's been a couple of mentions of Rust4Linux in the past week or two, one from Linus on the speed of engagement and one about Wedson departing the project due to non-technical concerns. This got me thinking about project phases and developer types.
BITCOIN WELL — The fastest and safest way to buy bitcoin in Canada
The new JB server - KTZ systems — Join Alex, Chris, and Brent as we fly to Toronto to deploy our shiny new colo server in Canada. We'll be deploying the 45homelab HL15 server.
OpenEBS — OpenEBS is a modern Block-Mode storage platform, a Hyper-Converged software Storage System and virtual NVMe-oF SAN (vSAN) Fabric that is natively integrates into the core of Kubernetes.
Install Shotcut on Flathub — Shotcut supports many video, audio, and image formats via FFmpeg and screen, webcam, and audio capture. It uses a time-line for non-linear video editing of multiple tracks that may be composed of various file formats. Scrubbing and transport control are assisted by OpenGL GPU-based processing and a number of video and audio filters are available.
Bonus Pick: Butler — Access your Home Assistant dashboard from a native companion UI, integrating better with your OS.
Redox OS — Redox is a Unix-like general-purpose microkernel-based operating system written in Rust, aiming to bring the innovations of Rust to a modern microkernel, a full set of programs and be a complete alternative to Linux and BSD.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode