The Downside with Gianmarco Soresi #332 Kim Kardashian’s “All’s Fair” Is The Greatest Show I’ve Ever Seen (Patreon Excerpt)
Nov 29, 2025
Join Gianmarco and Russell as they dissect the quirks of Ryan Murphy's new show starring Kim Kardashian. They delve into its bizarre stylistic choices and the odd tone that oscillates between humor and drama. The hosts explore standout performances, including a poignant breakup scene featuring Glenn Close. They critique the show's awkward dialogue and sexual contradictions, while debating whether it's intentionally comedic or earnest. Prepare for hilarious insights into a series that mixes high drama with cringe-worthy moments!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
A Unique, Unclassifiable TV Experiment
- Gianmarco and Russell find All's Fair unlike anything they've seen, blending high-caliber actors with Kim Kardashian's raw presence.
- They call it hyper-stylized, sexified and visually driven in a way that defies conventional categorization.
Sexual Style And Emotional Distance
- The hosts note a dissonance where the show is hypersexual but feels sexless and oddly non-interactive in scenes.
- They argue the writing often reads as nonspecific and oddly unaware of legal or real-world detail.
Glamour Meets Illogical Procedure
- Gianmarco and Russell highlight that the show compresses elite lifestyles with procedural work, creating surreal role mixes.
- They criticize sloppy exposition and lack of specificity in dialogue and plot details.