Just War Zombie Apocalypses? (and more Weird Questions)
Jan 3, 2025
auto_awesome
Cy Kellett, a regular on Catholic Answers Live known for his knack for quirky inquiries, joins Jimmy Akin to tackle some bizarre questions. They muse over whether Just War doctrine could come into play during a zombie apocalypse and discuss if organ transplants can transfer baptismal graces. The duo also ventures into the afterlife of fictional Time Lords and explores the fascinating concept of divine grace across multiple timelines. Plus, they dive into marine spirits and the quirky moral dilemmas of heavenly existence.
The podcast discusses the application of Just War doctrine in a zombie apocalypse, emphasizing the need to respect human dignity amid aggression.
It explores complex theological questions such as whether baptized organs can convey grace, concluding that only the physical organ is transferred.
Deep dives
Multiple Dimensions of Time
The discussion explores the theoretical possibility of a universe with multiple dimensions of time, positing that such a scenario does not contain any logical contradictions. Depending on how God creates these time dimensions and their interrelations, our perception of time could vary greatly. The idea of a universe with discrete units of time, akin to taxi cab geometry, is presented as a potential framework, implying we may perceive time as a flow without recognizing its underlying structure. Ultimately, the nature of time in such a universe would depend on God's design and choice.
Baptismal Graces in Transplants
The question of whether a baptized person's organ can transmit baptismal graces to an unbaptized recipient is analyzed, concluding that only the physical organ is transferred, not the recipient's spiritual state. While there are anecdotal accounts of organ transplant recipients experiencing changes in preferences or memories from donors, the debate over the soul's integration remains complex. Catholic theology is referenced, discussing the possibility of multiple forms within the body, but it is argued that baptism applies to the entire person rather than isolated organs. Thus, the recipient would still need baptismal grace acquired through personal baptism.
The Atonement and Alternate Realities
The notion of whether Christ's atonement extends to beings in alternate realities is examined, with the understanding that the death of Christ has infinite value. If alternate universes were to exist as branches from our timeline, the impact of Jesus's sacrifice could hypothetically span over these realities. However, whether this grace would actually apply to beings in those realms is entirely dependent on God’s choice. Ultimately, the discussion reflects on God's sovereign will regarding the application of Christ’s redemptive act across possible multiverses.
Just War Theory in a Zombie Apocalypse
In a hypothetical zombie apocalypse, the principles of just war doctrine would still broadly apply, particularly in ensuring that actions taken respect human dignity even in the face of irrational aggression. Given that zombies are typically portrayed as non-rational entities, traditional obligations for negotiation would not stand, allowing for immediate defensive action. The morality surrounding lethal force would hinge on whether the zombies are seen as living beings capable of being cured, changing the ethical landscape significantly. Thus, the application of warfare ethics in such scenarios becomes nuanced and dependent on the nature of the threat posed by the zombies.
For New Year's week, Jimmy Akin is answering more weird questions posed by Cy Kellett, including whether Just War doctrine applies to a zombie apocalypse; does a transplanted organ transfer baptismal graces; do Time Lords go to heaven; and more!