The Athletic FC Podcast The Preview: Arsenal vs Man United
24 snips
Jan 23, 2026 Art de Roché, tactical reporter known for sharp match analysis, and Stu James, football journalist with Premier League insight, preview Arsenal vs Manchester United. They debate Carrick’s tactics, United personnel choices and Mbouma as a striker. They also dissect Arsenal’s San Siro performance, squad depth and the wider weekend fixtures including City, Newcastle, Villa and Chelsea.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Casemiro: High Cost, Limited Long-Term Value
- Casemiro's transfer was always risky given his age and huge cost, so transformational impact was unlikely.
- Stu James says his good moments still outweighed the bad but resale value made the deal structurally flawed.
United's Derby Was Tactical And Emotional
- Manchester United's win over City was both tactical and emotional under Michael Carrick.
- Stu James highlights controlled aggression, strong centre-back display and effective counter-attacks as key factors.
Adjust Tactics Against Arsenal, Don't Repeat City Plan
- Do expect Carrick to adapt tactics versus Arsenal rather than simply replicate the City approach.
- Art de Roché warns attacking Arsenal like City did could play into Arsenal's hands and suggests a cautious switch is sensible.