Judith Butler Can’t “Take Credit or Blame” for Gender Furor
Mar 15, 2024
auto_awesome
The podcast explores the escalating legal assault on trans rights by conservative groups, focusing on nearly five hundred bills introduced across the country. It delves into Judith Butler's influential ideas on gender as a social construct and her identification as nonbinary. The discussion covers the backlash to trans rights, gender politics, identity fluidity, compassion in gender discourse, and the intricate relationship between gender beliefs and political narratives.
Conservative groups are escalating legal assaults on trans rights with over 500 bills introduced, creating a concerning trend nationwide.
Judith Butler's work challenges traditional gender views by emphasizing gender as a social construct enacted through behaviors, influencing younger generations for more inclusivity.
Deep dives
Anti-Trans Legislation in the United States
State legislatures in the United States have introduced numerous bills aiming to restrict the rights of trans Americans. These bills, although not all passed into law, reflect a concerning trend across the country. For example, Florida implemented laws such as a ban on gender affirming care for transgender youth and restrictions on healthcare for transgender adults, leading to clinic closures. Additionally, Florida's criminal bathroom ban poses challenges for trans individuals, enforced through self-policing and potential legal actions.
Business Response to Anti-Trans Legislation
Despite past backlash from the business community against anti-trans measures, current responses vary. Some chambers of commerce have voiced concerns about the negative impact of such bills on local economies and inclusivity. However, many businesses are less vocal due to fears of reprisal, including bomb threats and harassment. This environment has made it challenging for businesses to take a firm stand against anti-trans legislation.
Judith Butler and Gender Theory
Judith Butler, a prominent figure in gender theory, emphasizes the performative nature of gender. Their work, notably 'Gender Trouble,' introduced the idea that gender is a social construct enacted through behaviors. This concept challenges traditional binary views of gender, advocating for a broader understanding that includes various gender identities. Butler's theories have significantly influenced younger generations' perspectives on gender, fostering more complex and inclusive views.
Pronouns and Recognition
The use of correct pronouns is vital for recognizing and respecting individuals' gender identities. While adapting to new pronouns can be initially challenging, it signifies acknowledging and validating a person's self-identification. Judith Butler highlights the importance of pronouns in affirming an individual's identity and emphasizes the need for compassion when corrections are made. They underscore the significance of listening to and honoring individuals' gender expressions for a more inclusive society.
A legal assault on trans rights by conservative groups and the Republican Party is escalating, the journalist Erin Reed reports, with nearly five hundred bills introduced across the country so far this year. Reed spoke with the Radio Hour about the tactics being employed. But long before gender theory became a principal target of the right, it existed principally in academic circles. And one of the leading thinkers in the field was the philosopher Judith Butler. In “Gender Trouble” (from 1990) and in other works, Butler popularized ideas about gender as a social construct, a “performance,” a matter of learned behavior. Those ideas proved highly influential for a younger generation, and Butler became the target of traditionalists who abhorred them. A protest at which Butler was burned in effigy, depicted as a witch, inspired their new book, “Who’s Afraid of Gender?” It covers the backlash to trans rights in which conservatives from the Vatican to Vladimir Putin create a “phantasm” of gender as a destructive force. “Obviously, nobody who is thinking about gender . . . is saying you can’t be a mother, that you can’t be a father, or we’re not using those words anymore,” they tell David Remnick. “Or we’re going to take your sex away.” They also discuss Butler’s identification as nonbinary after many years of identifying as a woman. “The younger generation gave me ‘they,’ ” as Butler puts it. “At the end of ‘Gender Trouble,’ in 1990, I said, ‘Why do we restrict ourselves to thinking there are only men and women?’ . . . This generation has come along with the idea of being nonbinary. Never occurred to me. Then I thought, Of course I am. What else would I be? . . . I just feel gratitude to the younger generation, they gave me something wonderful. That takes a certain humility.”
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode