First Things Podcast Law on Film (ft. Stanley Fish)
May 15, 2025
Stanley Fish, a renowned scholar of Milton and author of 'Law at the Movies,' dives into the fascinating interplay between law and film. He critiques the courtroom dynamics in films like '12 Angry Men,' emphasizing how these narratives reflect moral complexities. Fish discusses the clash of secular law and religious influence in 'Inherit the Wind,' highlighting its simplistic portrayal of legal arguments. He also explores the implications of modern libel law against the backdrop of fake news, using films like 'The People vs. Larry Flynt' as a lens.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
12 Angry Men Juror Debate
- In "12 Angry Men," jurors debate the concept of reasonable doubt through detailed legal discussions.
- Henry Fonda's character moves all jurors from guilty to innocent by questioning evidence and biases.
Film Uses Actor's Persona Persuasively
- The film "12 Angry Men" uses Henry Fonda's iconic trustworthy persona to manipulate viewers into trusting his character.
- Visual cues like his white suit and height enhance the persuasion that skepticism reveals truth.
Law Depends on Violence and Legend
- "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance" shows law's authority rests on underlying violence and legend.
- John Wayne's murder of Liberty Valance behind the scenes grants law its social legitimacy despite its violent origin.