Philosopher John Stuart Mill discusses the complexities of moral decisions, the role of utilitarian principles, and his views on liberty and freedom. The podcast explores Mill's harm principle, contrasts negative and positive freedom, and emphasizes critical examination of philosophical beliefs.
Kant's universal law in ethics vs. utilitarianism for maximizing happiness
John Stuart Mill's harm principle limits state intervention to prevent harm, not offenses
Deep dives
Models of Moral Reasoning: Kant vs. Utilitarianism
Different models of moral reasoning, such as Kant's ethical theory and utilitarianism, were discussed in the podcast. Kant proposed that we should always act in a way that the rule of our action could be willed as a universal law, while utilitarianism focuses on bringing the greatest happiness for the greatest number. An objection raised was the conflict in situations where two good principles collide, leaving you to choose one, highlighting the challenges of moral decision-making.
Applying Mill's Harm Principle
John Stuart Mill's harm principle, which states that social coercion is justified only to prevent harm to others, was explored. The principle emphasizes that the state should intervene only to prevent genuine harm and not offenses. This principle has been critiqued in various contexts, including issues like pornography and war toys, to determine the boundaries of social coercion.
Freedom: Negative vs. Positive Concepts
The distinction between negative and positive freedom concepts was highlighted in the podcast. Negative freedom revolves around freedom from constraints, as advocated by John Stuart Mill, while positive freedom focuses on enabling freedom to pursue certain actions. The discussion emphasized the significance of positive freedom in enabling individuals to exercise their rights and pursue their goals.
Hegel's Historical Concept of Freedom
Hegel's view on freedom as a historical concept that evolves through the overcoming of obstacles to attain concrete goals was discussed. Freedom in Hegel's philosophy is not just about absence of constraints but is embedded in human history and the constant struggle for realization. The podcast emphasized the importance of historical context in understanding the dynamic nature of freedom and the ongoing pursuit of individual and societal liberties.
John Stuart Mill on Liberty LECTURE ON ETHIC JOHN STUART MILL ON LIBERTY
THE INTELLECTUAL DARK WEB PODCAST
We Search the Web for the Best Intellectual Dark Web Podcasts, Lectures and Videos that can be understood by merely listening to save YOUR time. Then we make those Intellectual Dark Web Episodes available on Spotify and downloadable.
IMPORTANT!
GET THE MAIN WORKS OF HOBBES, LOCKE, ROUSSEAU / MACHIAVELLI AND THE US CONSTITUTION BOUND TOGETHER IN JUST ONE PRACTICAL BOOK:
This DIN A4 paperback with glossy book cover printed on thick white paper contains the following original reprints in full:
The Prince (1532) by Niccolo Machiavelli
The Leviathan (1651) by Thomas Hobbes
The Two Treatises of Government (1689) by John Locke
The Social Contract (1762) by Jean-Jacques Rousseau
The Constitution of Pennsylvania (1776) by The Founding Fathers of the United States of America