Blue Jays Talk Jays Suffer Major Meltdown, Fall Behind 3-2 in ALCS
Oct 18, 2025
Jeff Blair and Kevin Barker dissect the Blue Jays' frustrating 6-2 loss to the Mariners in Game 5 of the ALCS. They intensely debate John Schneider's controversial decision to bring in Brendan Little over more trusted relievers. Fans express outrage over the move, questioning its timing and implications. The hosts also discuss George Springer's knee injury, the emotional fallout from the loss, and what the team must do to bounce back in Game 6. Historical comparisons heighten the stakes as the pressure mounts for the Blue Jays.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Managerial Move Shifted Momentum
- The hosts view John Schneider's eighth-inning decision as the defining moment of the loss and series momentum shift.
- Using Brandon Little instead of Hoffman or Domínguez turned a one-run lead into a five-run inning and revived Seattle.
Best Arms Left On Bench Criticized
- Barker and Blair argue two best arms were available and not used in the game's highest-leverage spot.
- They say the decision amplified scrutiny on management and could haunt Schneider if the Jays lose the series.
Lean On Trusted High-Leverage Arms
- Managers should put pitchers in positions that maximize their chances, especially in playoff high-leverage innings.
- When choice matters most, avoid overthinking; use trusted high-leverage arms rather than a roster gamble.