A devout father of 16 faces chilling FBI interrogation regarding a murder plot linked to a couple across the country. The story unravels dark familial ties and troubling motives surrounding his adopted children. Tensions rise as the agents delve into disturbing online activities and a network of past grievances. Amidst this, the Pence family's journey of compassion faces moral dilemmas and emotional turmoil. Themes of faith, community support, and the complexities of custody battles interlace, revealing the stark realities behind family bonds.
53:08
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The Pence family's devout religious lifestyle becomes the backdrop for a dark plot involving a murder-for-hire scheme initiated by Chris Pence.
Chris Pence's motivations for the murder plot stem from complex family dynamics and his warped perception of protecting his adopted children.
Deep dives
The Pence Family Background
The Pence family, consisting of Chris and Michelle Pence and their 16 children, embodies a deep commitment to their faith as evangelical Christians. They maintain a routine that includes Bible study before schooling, highlighting their belief that children are blessings. Chris, an IT security expert, works remotely from their home in Utah, where they live in a spacious, multi-story house surrounded by a rugged landscape. This seemingly typical family life takes a dark turn when the FBI storms into their home to investigate a chilling murder-for-hire plot linked to Chris.
FBI Interrogation and the Kill List
Following the FBI's arrival, Chris Pence is taken for interrogation regarding a murder order he placed on a kill-for-hire website. The friendly demeanor of the agents contrasts sharply with the serious nature of their inquiries, as they seek to uncover the connection between Chris and the intended targets, Christina and Francisco, who are the biological parents of his adopted children. Despite the tension of the situation, Chris initially tries to downplay his understanding of the dark web, unaware that the agents already have substantial evidence against him. This interrogation reveals layers of complexity concerning motive and the strained family dynamics at play.
The Adoption Story
Chris and Michelle Pence adopted five children from Christina and Francisco, who had approached them in desperate need of assistance for their family. After initially meeting in Massachusetts, the Pences agreed to take the children temporarily, believing they were rescuing them from unsafe conditions. Over time, the adoption turned into a more permanent arrangement after Christina and Francisco were worried about the Massachusetts Department of Children and Families potentially splitting their family apart. This complicated their relationship, with ongoing visits causing tension and confusion, particularly as the Pence children began facing behavioral issues stemming from this abrupt shift.
Allegations and Conflicting Narratives
The situation escalated when allegations of abuse arose against Christina and Francisco, with Chris claiming they were unfit parents and posing a risk to the wellbeing of their children. He justified his murder plot based on his belief that the birth parents were trying to regain custody, despite Christina's insistence that they were not pursuing any legal actions for their children's return. The conflicting narratives between the Pence and the birth parents raise serious questions about the truth behind the allegations of abuse and the motivations driving Chris' drastic actions. Chris ultimately confesses to the FBI that paying for the murder of the couple was supposed to protect the children, illuminating a tragic misrepresentation of his paternal instincts that led to significant consequences for all involved.
The home of a devoutly religious father of 16 children is raided and he’s then interrogated in the backseat of an SUV. The FBI agents questioning him want to know: what connects him to a couple on the other side of the country? And why does he want them dead?
Follow the Kill List on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. You can binge all episodes early and ad-free on Wondery+. Join Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Start your free trial by visiting www.wondery.com/links/kill-list now.