Wrong about the gift of prophecy: 10 Qs with Mike Winger (Ep 44)
Feb 8, 2025
auto_awesome
This discussion dives into the controversial nature of prophecy, questioning whether it must always be positive. It tackles the balance of giving time versus money, emphasizing responsibility alongside generosity. The parable of the wedding feast is unpacked, revealing its profound significance for salvation. The conversation also examines God's motivations and the complexities of baptism related to salvation. Lastly, the binding nature of vows made in sin is explored, along with lighthearted moments about accents in ministry.
01:31:55
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The podcast argues that prophetic messages can include difficult truths and should not be exclusively positive or encouraging.
It highlights the importance of discernment in prophecy, stressing the need for alignment with biblical teachings to avoid spiritual stagnation.
The discussion addresses the practice of praying over objects, inviting reflection on intent and the risk of straying into superstition.
Deep dives
Understanding Prophecy and Its Nature
The podcast discusses the perception of prophecy within the Christian community, particularly focusing on the idea that prophetic messages should always be positive. It references 1 Corinthians 14:3, where prophecy is said to be meant for building up, encouraging, and comforting people. The speaker challenges this notion by questioning whether a prophetic word can include negative aspects, such as calling out sin or moral failure. The discussion emphasizes that not all prophetic messages are meant to be uplifting, as history shows instances where prophets delivered harsh truths for the sake of repentance and growth.
The Role of Scripture in Evaluating Prophetic Words
The speaker critiques the viewpoint held by some charismatic leaders that prophecies should exclusively encourage individuals without addressing negative behaviors or sins. Citing examples from the Old Testament, the speaker illustrates that prophets often had to deliver difficult messages to encourage repentance and accountability. This important voice of accountability serves as a reminder that true prophetic ministry can involve confronting sin to facilitate growth in faith. The session highlights the necessary balance between encouragement and confrontation in delivering prophetic messages.
Exploring the Concept of Encouragement in Prophecy
The podcast delves into the specific call for prophets to focus on only delivering encouraging messages, often discrediting any that may address sin or judgment. It mentions Chris Vallotton's view that prophetic words should, at all costs, offer solutions rather than discuss problems. The speaker counters by arguing that this approach risks providing false positivity, which could lead to detrimental consequences for individuals unable to recognize their need for change. This refusal to bring up difficult truths can create a harmful environment where sin goes unacknowledged.
The Historical Context of Negative Prophecies
Historical examples are highlighted to demonstrate that negative prophetic messages have significant scriptural support as seen in the lives of prophets like Jeremiah and Isaiah. These prophets delivered difficult words at times, warning nations of judgment for their sins and calling for repentance. The podcast suggests that receiving a reprimand or corrective message can be more beneficial than merely hearing affirmations. This historical context reinforces the argument that genuine prophetic voices often encapsulate both encouragement and difficult truths as part of their ministry.
The Importance of Discernment in Prophetic Ministry
The podcast emphasizes the need for discernment within the context of prophecy, suggesting that merely accepting positive words without testing their truth against scripture can lead to spiritual stagnation. The speaker warns against the dangers of a prophetic practice that only affirms positive behaviors, arguing that this can result in a lack of accountability. Drawing on various New Testament references, the discussion underscores the necessity of aligning prophetic words with biblical teachings. This holistic approach encourages believers to seek the fullness of truth that encompasses both affirmation and correction when necessary.
Praying Over Objects: Superstition or Scriptural Basis?
The speaker addresses a question about the practice of praying over objects or homes, debating whether this can fall into superstitious rituals. The podcast cites biblical precedent seen in the anointing of the temple and other ceremonial acts commanded by God. It highlights the importance of intent behind such prayers, stating that they may be valid if they resonate with faith in God’s protection or guidance. However, the discussion warns against falling into rituals that could lead to straying into superstition, encouraging believers to stay firmly rooted in scripture.
1. 0:26 {Prophecy Always Positive?} Is the gift of prophecy always supposed to yield a positive, uplifting revelation? 2. 20:38 {Praying Over Things?} What are your thoughts on praying over a house or object? Is that superstition? 3. 24:23 {Giving Time vs. Money?} Is it ever OK to give time instead of money to church? How do we balance giving vs. saving, especially if giving might cause debt (Mark 12:41-44, Romans 13:1-8)? I also have a family to provide for. 4. 31:18 {Parable of the Wedding Feast} Can you please explain the parable in Matthew 22:1-14 (The Parable of the Wedding Feast)? I don’t understand the meaning. 5. 40:06 {Should I Be Rebaptized?} I fell out of the faith years ago and recently came back and feel like I should get baptized again. Is there anything for or against this in the Bible? 6. 47:26 {Is God Selfish?} Do you believe that God is selfish in everything He does? It seems even His "selfless" acts are done for His own sake (Psalm 106:8, dying on the cross for His own glory, etc.). Would that motivation be wrong? 7. 56:56 {Is Baptismal Regeneration Heresy?} Is believing that baptism is for the remission of sins based on Acts 2: 38 heresy? Is someone who was thusly baptized then not saved? 8. 1:11:49 {Sinful Vows: Binding?} Are vows made in sin or amidst sinful circumstances still binding in eyes of God (Ecclesiastes 5:5, Joshua 9, Genesis 27, Judges 12)? 9. 1:16:29 {Isaiah 14: About Satan?} Is Isaiah 14:3-20 about Satan? It says it is to the King of Babylon, but I have heard verses 12-14 used in reference to Satan. Just curious about your thoughts on it! 10. 1:24:02 {Did David Violate Deut. 24?} How was David able to take Michal back as his wife? Isn’t that a violation of Deuteronomy 24, and does that apply today?
My first video on Bethel showing the problem of faking prophecy: Click Here
My second video on Bethel, showing there are major problems beyond what I was aware of in the first video. Bethel continues to have worldwide influence: Click Here
Who wrote the Gospel of Mark? (lots of evidence): Click Here
I do this live stream most Fridays at 1 p.m. Pacific Time. You're welcome to join. To ask a question, you'll need to follow these instructions: 1. Don't post your question before you see me live on camera. 2. Post questions as comments in the LIVE chat at the beginning of the stream. 3. Post your question with "Q" at the beginning so we can easily identify that you are sending it in as a question for me and not just a comment in the chat. 4. Try to be as clear as possible so I won't misunderstand the question. Keep in mind that I don't know anything about your question other than what you type in that short comment. 5. Include specific verse references when possible or applicable. 6. Only one question submitted per subscriber, per stream, please. Submitting the same question into the chat a few times is OK. 7. Please understand that we don't strictly take the first 10 questions submitted. Our team takes several factors into consideration. 8. Check the Clip Search on BibleThinker.org in advance to see if your topic of interest has already been covered in a past session.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode