The Work Yet to Be Done to Free Workers from State Licensing
Dec 9, 2024
auto_awesome
Ed Timmons, Director of the NEE Regulatory Research Center, dives into the world of state-level occupational licensing. He reveals that a staggering one in three jobs requires a license, creating barriers to workforce mobility. Timmons questions the effectiveness of medical licensing and highlights the impact of excessive regulations on economic progress. He advocates for universal license recognition to ease transitions between states and discusses recent reforms in Ohio to improve board impartiality. The discussion underscores the need to streamline licensing to boost workforce participation.
Occupational licensing has surged from one in ten to one in three jobs licensed, restricting economic competition and job access.
Reform efforts for universal license recognition across states may unintentionally solidify existing regulations instead of reducing them.
Deep dives
The Impact of Occupational Licensing on Economic Performance
Occupational licensing significantly hampers economic performance, with states enacting more licenses over time. Historically, only one in ten occupations were licensed, but that number has increased to about one in three. This growth in regulation often restricts competition and keeps individuals out of the job market, thus limiting economic opportunities. For example, Texas licenses 199 out of 284 examined occupations, the highest in the study, while Kansas licenses only 136, illustrating the stark differences in regulatory approaches across states.
Unique Licensing Practices and State Variability
The variability in state licensing practices reveals that some states regulate occupations that others do not, leading to peculiar outcomes. For instance, Rhode Island exclusively licenses a lightning remediation contractor, a profession not recognized by any other state. This raises the question of why certain states, like Texas, impose these unique licensing requirements, which often seem unnecessary. By highlighting these unusual cases, we can better understand the broader implications of licensing regulations on economic freedom and labor supply.
Proposals for Reform and the Future of Licensing
Efforts for reform in occupational licensing are gaining traction, especially with the push for universal recognition of licenses across states. Currently, 26 states have implemented such recognition, which helps streamline the process for licensed professionals moving between states. However, there is a concern that this could inadvertently entrench existing licensing regimes rather than eliminate them. A more profound reduction in licensing requirements could enhance labor force participation, as evidenced by studies showing licensing can lower labor supply by up to 29%, indicating the potential for increased job opportunities by simplifying regulations.