The Opinions

The World’s Best and Brightest Are Moving, but Not to America

9 snips
Jul 9, 2025
Lydia Polgreen, an Opinion columnist at The New York Times and former foreign correspondent, shares her insights on global migration trends. She discusses how Trump's immigration policies have reshaped notions of citizenship and belonging in America. The conversation highlights the competition for talent worldwide and the irony of countries tightening borders while migrants seek opportunities at home. Personal narratives illuminate the emotional experiences tied to identity and belonging, shedding light on the struggles and aspirations of displaced individuals.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Shifting Global Migration Patterns

  • Migration patterns are shifting as poorer countries' best and brightest opt for new global hubs like Dubai rather than traditional Western destinations.
  • Immigrants now seek respect and professional opportunity over just entry, challenging old assumptions about immigrant desires.
INSIGHT

Why Top Talent Is Choosing Dubai Over America

Countries are increasingly competing to attract immigrants, especially skilled workers, because people are the scarcest resource globally.

Lydia Polgreen highlights that many migrants no longer see the U.S. or Western Europe as their default destinations. Instead, places like Dubai attract talented immigrants due to perceived opportunities and professional respect without the indignities often experienced during immigration processes in Western countries.

An example is a Ugandan lawyer who thrived in Dubai, preferring participation in a country's economy over permanent citizenship. This shift signals a move from immigration as a path to belonging to immigration as a transactional participation based on mutual benefit.

This dynamic challenges long-held assumptions about migration and the nature of citizenship and belonging in a changing global landscape.

ANECDOTE

Lydia's Family Immigration Story

  • Lydia Polgreen shared her personal connection as the child of an immigrant whose parents faced professional setbacks despite high qualifications.
  • This highlights immigrant experiences of skill underutilization and the challenges of belonging.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app